MovieChat Forums > Gina Carano Discussion > Outrage after Gina Carano compares being...

Outrage after Gina Carano compares being a Republican to being a Jew under Nazi Germany


https://variety.com/2021/tv/news/gina-carano-mandalorian-controversy-twitter-1234905140/

reply

First, while the comparison isn't a perfect parallel, it is apt. Second, of course it is jews complaining, they like to have a monopoly on their persecution complex. Third, they should give it a break as only a small few of Jews still alive actually lived through that (and it isn't those Jews raising a fuss). Those jews complaining so bitterly about this, have lived their whole lives as free citizens in a free country.

reply

You're a disgusting antisemitic scum.

reply

Nope. I am just outraged that they are outraged over something they shouldn't be. It is just faux outrage anyway. They aren't really upset she made the comparison, they are upset over her politics.

reply

@TearofLys: I salute you for your common sense approach and factual post.

reply

ditto

reply

Agreed. Well put! Media has been after her for a bit now. Ok, it wasn't the best comparison, nor was it overly smart of her to make it, but it wasn't making light in any way of the holocaust... She was making a parallel to the early days and she isn't exactly wrong, anyone with a brain can see that there is a minor comparison which could be made there.

reply

No, outrage over her comparison is PERFECTLY VALID. It's a piss poor and frankly disgusting comparison - and I say this as someone who despises the liberal mob and absolutely recognizes they are trying to make disagreeing illegal. But cancel culture is not remotely comparable to mass murder. STOP. IT.

reply

Someone else who didn't get her tweet.

She was referencing the build up th WW2 in 1930's Germany were the German Government started a campaign to blame Jews for all the countries wrongs and make everyday people turn aganst them. So when the war broke out it was much easier for the soldiers to round them up.

Just like today were having a political opinion different from the left will get you attacked, banned off Twitter and even mentions of drone strikes all for having a different political opinion. That is what she is referencing. It is truely amazing how many times you need to point his out to people.

Nothing in her tweet referenced the holocaust, if you see that then that is on you.

reply

"Nothing in her tweet referenced the holocaust, if you see that then that is on you."

Oh, was she referring to the other mass murder incident/period in history?

You sound insane.

reply

She was referencing 1930 Germany. WW2 started in 1944.

Learn to read. Her tweet never once referenced the holocaust. You just want it to be so you can be the very definition of outrage virtue signalling.

You literally have no clue what she wrote so you spout the same lies that got her fired.

She was referencing the treatment the Jews got in 1930's Germany which led to the holocaust not the holocaust itself. Again, she referenced the lead up to it, I wrote that twice for the hard of hearing.

She used it as an example as that is what is happening with cancel culture where ordinary people are attacking other people based solely on the fact they are republican.

Aganit isn't hard to see, you just don't want to.

reply

" You just want it to be so you can be the very definition of outragte virtua signalling"

Don't talk to me about comprehension. Literally the comment you responded to:

"and I say this as someone who despises the liberal mob and absolutely recognizes they are trying to make disagreeing illegal."

reply

Stop trying to back track and at least wait until my post is complete, which you didn't

You said she referenced the holocaust and I am pointing out that she didn't, not even close.

If you cannot comprehend her tweet correctly then you shouldn't respond to it as what ever you say will be false just like all the idiots on Twitter who went on their usual fake outrage over stuff they really don't give a shit about. They just want the likes and retweets to make their pathetic lives seem to have some value.

But if you wanna go down that road then why has Pedro Pascal not also been fired for referencing the Holocaust?

reply

Backtrack, LOL?! Bahahahahahah! I posted a QUOTE from MY comment. You know, the one you responded to?

reply

Yeh that is how discussion goes. You say something and someone replies.

Or do you expect no one to question anything you say.

Once again you stated that she referenced the holocaust which she didn't. If you see that then that is your issue not hers, you are just the same as the vile scum who attacked her on Twitter and got her fired.

I'l wait for the poor rebuttal if you have one in you.

reply

Can you post a QUOTE from Gina comparing the Holocaust with whatever you think she did?

reply

forget it, discussing with these low IQ left wing fucks is hopeless.

reply

Is he wrong though, and do you have a counter argument, or just worthless emotions?

reply

counter argument to what? "jews are evil and run the world"?

reply

Outside of your post where does "jews are evil and run the world" appear in this thread?

reply

Read between the lines.

reply

As I suspected you lied.

reply

Of course a Proud Boys member wouldn't see anything wrong with his post.

reply

People like you are the reason western society is in fucking ruins.
"EVERYONE WHO DISAGREES WITH ME IS A NAZI!"

Fucking idiot.

reply

if the shoe fits...

reply

TheArgentinian is the biggest Fucking idiot on movie chat

reply

your hatred is really bumming me out

reply

says the alt-right white supremacist nazi.

reply

Your buzzwords are meaningless.

reply

I'm a woke, virtue signaling SJW, what can I say *shrugs*

reply

TheArgentinian is the biggest Fucking idiot on movie chat

reply

No he isn't.

reply

Flocks of a feather...

reply

OY VEY SHUT IT DOWN THE GOYIM KNOW!

reply

See, everyone?

reply

Funny your screen name is the same country all the Nazis fled to.

reply

"You're a disgusting antisemitic scum."

And you are a piece of shit with low IQ

And 99% of moviechat agrees on that.

reply

99% of people in your head?

reply

Jews are a protected group, like blacks. But, if you're Asian, you have no value. Disney had no problem shooting "Mulan" where China has its concentration camps, and having a lead actress who supports Communism and fights against democracy.

Just like Mel Gibson, you cross the line with a protected group, you're done.

reply

FUCK THOSE SOFT SPINED PEOPLE...MAKING A COMPARISON?...OH WELL...GET OVER IT.

reply

She is saying that people being criticized for their political beliefs have it as bad as people that were hunted, gathered up, put in prison, tortured, and murdered. That is the comparison she's making. Just think for one second, will you?

reply

OH REALLY?...SHE SAID IT?...LIKE WITH WORDS?...YOU KNOW...STICKS AND STONES...WORDS CAN NEVER HURT YOU...WHO FUCKING CARES WHAT SOMEONE THINKS/SAYS...WE DONT ALL HAVE THE SAME THOUGHTS OR BELIEFS...GROW UP.

reply

How the hell do you think the Holocaust all began? Do you suppose they were loading Jews in trains and sending them to die in the camps from the get-go? The Holocaust BEGAN with criticism and demonization and negative portrayals of Jews in media. Step one in a process.

reply

This!

reply

She never said they had it *exactly* as bad. But, Big Tech oligarchs and tyrannical political leaders are conspiring (very fascistic right there) to boot people like her from presumably public platforms, deny them access to banking, and are hunting them down. The FBI is spending millions to hunt down unarmed peaceful protestors and charge them with fucking sedition, while they let ANTIFA/BLM (brownshirts) terrorize right wing groups and burn cities to the ground all summer without lifting a finger. Jay Danielson was murdered by these brownshirts that the tyrants let roam free and Kyle Rittenhouse is imprisoned for defending himself against these brownshirts.

The only reason you don't see these parallels is because you have your eyes closed.

reply

This isn't correct.
first of all, some of those that breached the Capitol committed murder (the cop that was bludgeoned to death - remember?) and many others did vandalize the place and looted, just like the BLM scum did all summer.
Second, the BLM scum was and still is persecuted. Many were even grabbed right off the streets from special police forces without identification in unmarked rental vans.

However, not enough was and is done against the BLM terror group and now with sockpuppet POTUS, expect the opposite - direct support of BLM. Harris' stance in all this is alarmingly clear and some things she said should make your skin crawl.
And I agree on Ryttenhouse. A crystal clear case of self defense and considering the circumstances he showed very good discipline with his rifle, not endangering bystanders/panic shooting etc.

And those he killed?
Good riddance, let's be honest here for a moment.

reply

No cop was bludgeoned to death. Fake news. He only reported an adverse reaction to tear gas/pepper sparay and died of a stroke several days after the 6th..

trivial vandalization. There was no graffitti and nothing was set on fire. BLM/Antifa caused billions in damages over the summer.

Where are all these convictions of Antifa/BLM? All summer long, bought and paid for DAs dropped the charges. The feds really only went after one guy hard - that was the dude who murdered Jay Danielson in cold blood. Only because they couldn't ignore that one after we handed his identity over to them on a silver platter. Meanwhile, these protestors going on an unguided tour of the capitol are being hunted down and charged with sedtion.

reply

I think some democrats would do that if they could. Hell, some of them even want to kill Trump supporters with drone attacks...

reply

And many republicans would also do that if they could. It's certainly not one sided.

reply

Could you give me some examples? Republicans don't want that shit. They're not driven by hate like the democrats.

reply

It's more than "being criticized" with cancel culture. Cancel culture is about ruining people's careers and lives. They've been trying to get her fired for months and now she is. The comparison is wrong. It's off-base and offensive. Republicans are not being murdered for being Republican, but her overall point is true, no matter how bad her comparison was.

reply

It's like shitting your hotel bed just to prove that the hotel management are hostile towards you staying in their hotel, which is dirty anyway. "Just like the nazis were to the jews. "

reply

Aren't the soft spined people the ones claiming to be terrorized and oppressed for "being" a republican the same way the jews were terrorized and oppressed in 30s Germany for having been born into the jewish race?

reply

Honestly, I think she's trolling the twitter mobs by now. Just saying whatever will send them into a frothing rage.

Which doesn't make her comments inoffensive or anything, that is a monumentally dickish thing to say.

reply

It’s an accurate comparison the problem is Lucasfilm is run by a bunch of whack jobs until they clean house of Kathleen Kennedy and her minions.

reply

PReTenD ouTragE is best outRagE.

reply

Yeah. Carano pretending to be like a Jew under the nazis because people criticised her is the most bullshit outrage I've heard in years.

reply

Not what was said.

reply

https://www.bitchute.com/video/p4HLwiiziE71/

Here is Kamala (VP of the US) acting like a nazi
She has an eerily similar laughter to that of Hillary

reply

Dems are the worst, they can literally say and do anything and everyone just laughs. She makes a joke about Trump dying and everyone in the audience laughs, pretty sick.

reply

They can be as much outraged as they want, but the comparison is accurate.

When people think in Jews in Nazi Germany, they think in concentration camps. But that didn't happen until WW2. The situation of Jews in Germany during the 30s was quite similar to republicans right now: repression and fear.

Gina Carano herself is a good example of it. She hasn't been taken to a closed ghetto o a concentration camp, but she lost her job. Probably she has money enough to not to need it, but common people can be legitimately scared of losing their job because of some woke policy in their company.

reply

just read it , what i got from it what was:

"Dont hate people for having a different political view"

nicest thing i've read on the internet in a long time, especially on moviechat.

reply

Oh that's what you got? So it's fine to compare Democrats to Nazis, there's no hate against a political view happening there.

Are you blind?

reply

Might have been helpful if the OP had put in his post what she said, which was :

“Jews were beaten in the streets, not by Nazi soldiers but by their neighbors…even by children. Because history is edited, most people today don’t realize that to get to the point where Nazi soldiers could easily round up thousands of Jews, the government first made their own neighbors hate them simply for being Jews. How is that any different from hating someone for their political views,”


well , she didnt mention either party.
it could equally be saying the government , ie party in power , ie Republicans , are sowing hate against miniorities

reply

LOL, for that to be equal, twisting yourself into many pretzels would be required.

reply

Oh that's what you got?

Yes, because you did not get this at all.
Imagine there is a book containing all the truth in the world (Really!) . Libtards would spend a lifetime to find the single word in this book that they can call "inappropriate", make a big fuss about it, and ignore the rest of the book totally. Because hey, who cares about all the truth in the world when only moaning and whining will make us happy?
Besides I don't call Carano's comparison clever because Nazis believed in a specific "Jewish race" they hated. As far as I know nobody discovered so far a "Republican race". Apples and oranges...

reply