MovieChat Forums > Superman (2025) Discussion > Shouldn't Lois Lane Really Have Been Bla...

Shouldn't Lois Lane Really Have Been Black In This One?


I think it would have been a refreshing take for cinema audiences to see a more diverse relationship on screen, such as that between a white (Super)man and a black women.

We rarely see this portrayed and it would have been nice to see a more bold casting choice for Superman to go beyond the already done race swapping of Perry White...

reply

Warner Bros is not Disney, they don't have as much money to lose like that.

Its share price dropped from the high of $77 in 2021 to about $10 today, while the overall sharemarkets have been booming. And they have been losing money for 2 straight years.

Disney however is still profitable.

Unlike Disney, Warner Bros chair and CEO both have been replaced in the past 2 years.

There is still going to be diversity casting, like a black Perry White (as always, ironic, isn't it? But there is Barry White, so I guess it is not uncommon), and Latino hawk girl, but not something as controversial as a black Lois Lane.

Go woke and go broke is no joke, at least not for Warner Bros.

reply

Sigh.

Shiera and Shayera Hol were the first two Hawkgirl/women characters. Then came Kendra Saunders, who has ALWAYS been Hispanic. Or Latino, or whatever the current acceptable lingo is (shrug). Point is: you (unsurprisingly) don't know what you're talking about. Hawkgirl's been "Latino" for the past Twenty Five Years.
Conclusion: the bleating about "diversity/woke" is often a knee-jerk, absurd reaction to anything that's not straight, male, and white.
I HATE race-swapping in CBMs, because I'm a purist: just put the version of the comic I grew up with on the screen, please. It's NOT HARD: the source material is literally a collection of storyboards. But it's clear that this is Not what most of the idiots bleating about these things are triggered by. Because NONE of them complained when Angelina Jolie played The Fox; and I happen to know for a fact that Halle Berry was available. #Period

reply

I don't read comic books also I know nothing about hawk girl, so thanks for the background information.

But it really does not change my main thesis, that Warner Bros not doing as much diversity casting due to their financial woes.

5 years ago Lois Lane being black would be almost a given.

reply

I'm not interested in changing your "thesis." I was bored, so simply pointed out your incorrect statement. Then added a couple amplifying facts explaining the contextual assumptions, stupidity and hypocrisy, then went about my day. Not bored any more, so. . .done w/this conversation. Shrug.

reply

No, you white hating bigot.

reply

Doesn't really make much sense as, like I said, Perry White is usually swapped so swapping Lois instead and making Perry White white is hardly white hating...

Besides I wasn't endorsing Michael B Jordan for Superman himself was I, so no reason to get so excited. Just looking for something refreshing for the franchise and cinema goers.

reply

We already got Michael B. Jordan as The Human Torch in the much failed Fantastic Four 4 from 2016

reply

Shouldn't Lois Lane Really Have Been Black In This One?
posted 11 hours ago by FootOfDavros (8310)
3 replies | jump to latest

I think it would have been a refreshing take for cinema audiences to see a more diverse relationship on screen, such as that between a white (Super)man and a black women.

We rarely see this portrayed and it would have been nice to see a more bold casting choice for Superman to go beyond the already done race swapping of Perry White"


No

reply

No.

Maybe a white man.

Or something really BOLD...a squirrel.

reply

Zoe Saldana was considered for Lois in MoS which actually probably would've been better casting than Amy Adams , but obviously she probably wouldn't have been in Guardians after

reply

Didn't you like Amy Adams?

I've seen she gets some grief but I thought she was okay and certainly better than Bosworth in Returns...

reply

Adams was far better than Bosworth who was wildly miscast;too young and too whiny.

reply

they should have at least cast a woman in the role

reply

The hell are you talking about?

Rachel Brosnahan is a hottie.

reply

They should have cast Carrot Top in the role, but alas missed out on the historic opportunity.

[none]

reply

They should've made her a black lesbian transsexual who identifies as a canine. That would really be "bold" and "progressive."

reply

This a thousand times this!!

Us Tran doggosexuals who make up .000347 % of population are entitled to.... nea DESERVE representation to be equal in every movie. We demand equal out come everywhere!!
Why, your ask?

Because we were born and deserve it for doing absolutely nothing to earn it.

We matter and you must hear about our sexuality.

reply