I have some issues with the film. Such as the logic behind the motivation of Thanos' plan and some very dumb choices that certain heroes make. But overall I would say it is a pretty great film. Definitely in the top 5 best Marvel films.
As for greatest Sci-Fi of all time? No. I would say it does not even qualify. And the simple reason for that is because this movie cannot stand on its own. Meaning 2 things specifically:
1.) Anyone who hasn't seen at least SOME of the Marvel films preceding it are going to be a little lost. That isn't to say that they won't be able to follow the primary plot but that is just a fact. I would say that its best to watch at least 'Civil War' and 'Ragnarok' beforehand, if not a few others as well.
2.) The movie ends on a cliffhanger. It doesn't have an ending. I understand this is an arguable point, since when taking this film from the perspective of the villain being the protagonist, he does actually accomplish his goal. But even when you take this away you're still left with point one.
In my estimation, a movie like this, which has no beginning or end, is more akin to 'Empire Strikes Back.' You can call it a great film. But its a great film with an incomplete story.
reply
share