Is this movie overhyped or is it really that good ??

I'ma go with 'Really that good'. I've seen it twice. Better the second time. In my humble opinion, of course, by FAR the best of the Wolverine films. Best of the Fox X-Men series of films. Best comic book/superhero film since 'The Dark Knight' (even though it doesn't have the feel of your typical comic book film at all), and I think it will age very well.

It has a lot of fundamental strengths. If you decide to see it, have tissues nearby. It makes people cry, and for the best of reasons.

Overhyped and overwrought. Very heavy handed attempts at drama and emotion which are obviously not this director 's forte.

I just bought and watched Logan on Blu Ray...I saw in it theaters and loved it, I came away believing it was one of the best CBM's ever....

I had it ranked #5 based off the 1 theater viewing.

But I just watched it again, I now have Logan as IMO The 2nd best CBM ever behind The Dark Knight and its Now ranked #3 for me personally as my Favorite CBM's...

IMO the 3 best CBM's ever are-
1. The Dark Knight
2. Logan
3. The Avengers

and My 3 favorite CBM's ever are-
1.The Avengers
2.The Dark Knight
3.Logan

Basically Yes LOGAN is really that good

Would give it a 7 out of ten. Was not "that" good but not bad either.

It's a very good movie, but there's no arguing that it was essentially Children of Men in a superhero outfit.

I noticed how overhyped it really was and in my opinion it's basically just that; Overhyped. It's a watchable, passable, but unremarkable movie that isn't really that good to deserve the hype. But that's just me, though.

Everyone has already forgotten about it, so yeah, overhyped.

It's not as good as people say it is, but they said a lot, so that'd be nearly impossible. It's an excellent film and well worth watching.