MovieChat Forums > Captain America: Brave New World (2025) Discussion > Is anyone even in favor of the new Cap?

Is anyone even in favor of the new Cap?


Doesn't seem to draw the same hype as the old one and he's been on the screen since Winter Soldier. I don't even think the Red Hulk will draw as much hype either with the type of energy Ford has been throwing around. Lot of his recent movies have been more or less flops since the past 5 years.

reply

Not unless he goes trans. That is what the audience wants.

reply

I mean, you had to of known that people have been used to Chris Evans in the role for like, EVER and making Mackie the title role just feels like it's pandering to Diversity for the sake of doing so??

reply

Captain America is more than just a guy with a shield.

He is a man out of time. He is superhuman. He is a VERY GOOD PERSON, morally speaking.

BUCKY should have gotten the shield, AND still NOT been renamed.

Falcon can still be his partner. Hell, he could be hte lead of the movie, But, Sam Wilson just is NOT the character of Captain America.

reply

I'll buy that

reply

So would I.

reply

In the comics, Sam Wilson was Cap's best friend and for a time, took over the mantle of Captain America when Steve was incapacitated.
So, it is not diversity being shoved down our throats.
Marvel was ahead of its time in having diverse characters.

reply

Marvel Comics has done everything and a pair of pants. That doesn't mean that all is taken seriously.

Captain America is not this guy, and nobody cares for him. This movie will be a flop unless they bait people with something, like a big ensemble, a famous villain or someone returning.

reply

Of course not. It's a comic book. Well, you have a right to your opinion, but, personally, I loved the idea of Cap having an African American friend. It showed that he was not racist. I also think they picked the perfect actor to portray him in the movies. I think Anthony Mackie did a great job.
Maybe the movie will be a flop. Only time will tell. I personally don't think so.

reply

I don't disagree with anything you said.
Anthony Mackie was a great side-kick.

Now to the topic being discussed - Anthony Mackie is going from side-kick, to main character. He doesn't have that charisma or even acting ability.
Worse than that, he goes from side-kick to straight up using the name and franchise of a previously known and loved character/actor. Clearly he is out of his league.

reply

You say To-ma-to, I say To-mah-to. We agree to disagree. And that's fine. That's what intellectual discourse is all about.

reply

When Sam originally took over the mantle in the comics, sales dropped so much that Marvel cut the storyline short. Fans want to see Steve Rogers as Captain America.

PS: I don't read comics anymore but I understand that there is a storyline going on right now where Steve and Sam are both Captain America. Don't know how that is going.

reply

Whenever I think of Cap I think of Evans. I never think of Mackie.

reply

Well, here's a little trivia: There actually was a Black Captain America named:

Isaiah Bradley

Considered to be the "Black Captain America", Isaiah Bradley is depicted as an underground legend among much of the African-American community in the Marvel Universe.

reply

So true!

reply

Shouldn't that be Captain Africa America?

reply

Hell no. It’s Rogers or no one.

reply

Naw. No one cares. It should've been Bucky, but Feige is a woke duck who thinks he can do whatever he wants and force the public to pay for it.

reply

Bucky would be a more interesting choice. Sam is good as Falcon, but he's not superhuman.

reply