But Sarah Looks NOTHING like Kimberly...

OMG!!!

First...They look very very similar Sarah just looks like a taller skinnier version...so Marne went on a diet boo hoo...thats all it look like..

Second...As for the name change...yes their name is Piper...their fathers name was William Piper...but becuase they were referred to as cromwells in the first movie so often that fact fell into the background because all of halloweentown knew them as CROMWELLS....Every movie on the planet has goofs...everyone needs to stop complaining about them fixing their mistake...it's the same character...

Third...You need to stop complaining about not having Kimberly as Marnie...She isn't working on this film for a reason...either they didn't want her because this is supposed to be later and they wanted her to look different. Or she refused to work on it maybe cause she didn't like the story or maybe cause she is working on another film...Either way...she isn't there for a reason...Sara is a talented actress so get over it...Kimberly and Disney did not have a contract for multiple halloweentown films....

Fourth....I seriously doubt that Sophie is not in this movie because they forgot about her...it's very improbable...somebody would have said something...the writers...the producers...the actors who play aggie, gwen, or dillan...there is a reason for her missing...and it probably isn't that the the actress wouldn't go for it...they would have replaced her too if that was the case...just wait for the movie and find out...or better yet go find the script cause it's somewhere online...guarenteed and find out what happens if your that desparate..

[deleted]

Okay don't hate me but I hate Sarah Paxton(duck!) I think she is a horrible actress(duck!) and looks nothing like Kimberly(i won't duck this time) i think Kim is a great actress and a perfect Marnie Cromwell. And I don't like the name change to 'Piper'. Well you wouldn't change your original last name if your mom got married. A boy at my schools dad died and his mom got remarried, but he didn't change his last name. I'm only tuning in to see Lucas Grabeel becuz i really think he is a good actor. but I will fall asleep and I'll comment after I get up. Now I've seen the preview, HORRIBLE ACTING! I've always loved the Halloweentown movies but this one WILL be bad.

Now don't give me lip I don't wanna hear your annoying comments!!!

I was so confused when i saw her on the commercials and i was like what? it made so sense to me and i am sure tons of little kids across the nation are wondering who the heck is this girl. Kimberly is kinda "larger" (no disrespect) and sara paxton is just taller and skinnier, they cant pull the wool over 7 year olds eyes. They have no idea what is going on but they know that this person isnt marnie. Disney also changed the last name to "Piper" which confused me also.

sorry, i didnt read all the post as i usually do.

"Work hard,learn well and make peace with the fact that you will never be as cool as Johnny Depp"

i kno u are so right, but y???, y replace sarah with kimberly the orginal character. i dont evn wanna watch ot wit sara in it. its all gonna be ewww all preppy ish and way to exicited then over doing it on the sad parts, its just- eww

I thought that it was Kimberly just 50lbs lighter. I was freaked out. I feel better now that I know that KJB hasn't fallen victim to Hollywood fads.

I agree it was stupid replacing her, i mean atleast get an actress that looks like her, but who cares whos playing her, as long as she plays the part right!

[deleted]