MovieChat Forums > Seraphim Falls (2007) Discussion > two scottish actors playing cowboys Hmmm...

two scottish actors playing cowboys Hmmmm?


the truth is that I love both Liam and Pierce and I couldn't wait to see this. Overall it is a good movie(slightly disapointed with the ending)

but as much as I love Liam and Pierce..I still found it rather odd that hollywood cast two scottish actors in the role of cowboys? Is there a problem with American actors? I mean I think George Clooney would have been great in Pierce's role and Gene Hackman in Liam's role


what say you?

do you find it strange that they cast two scottish actors in a western?

reply

They are both Irish!!

reply

The point is valid, but what you say is flawed on so many levels I hardly know where to start, or if it's intended as flame bait.

I think Pierce did an amazing job, Liam in my opinion did a forgettable performance and could've been replaced.

As for the whole nationality thing; on paper it's probably more realistic having people that aren't obvious current-day americans play western roles, but that's been proven to go both ways all depending on how their accents and personas are used in the movies.

reply

As Nelly Furtado once said "Hello Scotchland"

reply

George Clooney in Pierce's role? Are you kidding me?! GC is a pretty boy second rate actor. He get way more credit than he deserves.

reply

What a daft point anyway! There are tons of movies where British parts have been played by American actors! Such as Johnny Depp in Finding Neverland and Renee Zelwegger in Bridget Jones. So the question could be, what's up with British actors, you racist turd!

reply

Americans!!!? jesus christ.

where d'ya think ol' great granpappy etc came from ya phukin numpty bassa!!!???
I'll smack ye n the gub n mak ye greet, ya wee jessie!

Sorry 'bout that.
Haven't had my morning heroin.


"This is your Brain. This is your Brain on drugs. Any questions?"

reply

They're irish you idiot!!

reply

Don't forget that during the War Between The States, the largest "foreign" contingents who fought for both sides were Germans and Irish. The Union and Confederacy both had purely German regiments. Also, the Union had Irish regiments (eg remember the Irish Brigade of the Army of the Potomac ?) and the Confederacy had a number of Irish regiments (and famous generals such as Cleburne).

In the post-war US Army, Germans and particularly Irishmen formed a substantial part of the US Cavalry and Infantry etc through the Indian War period.

So I don't think the lilting Irish accent was strange to hear in the Wild and woolly West !

Faugh a ballagh !

You wanna f * * k with me? Okay. Say hello to my little friend! (Tony Montana)

reply

enough to be the leads in a western anymore. Maybe some of the older ones like Eastwood, and Hackman, but they would be slightly too old to play these roles.
I think the most masculine leading men come from other countries. At least, the ones with the most talent and the most ruggedness do.
Look at "3 10 to Yuma" starring a Welshman and a New Zealander. Perfect casting, even though they're playing Americans.
It's sad most of our younger leading men in Hollywood that are Americans, just don't have the bravado and ruggedness to pull off those kind of "manly men" roles.

reply

Hackman is too old for the part.

All I know is that it was a lot of fun to listen to them talk. "Grizzly" seems like a good adjective.

reply

[deleted]

p.s Great Britain consists of Northern Ireland (not Southern), Scotland, Wales and England and they can call themselves what they bloody like but they are all 'British' and have 'British' passports and are part of the United Kingdom of 'Great Britain' get it? Just like if you are a 'Californian' but you are also 'American'. Simple, look it up on the internet, it provides a wonderful amount of trivia.

You make me lol with your stupidity. Great Britain consists of England, Scotland and Wales. In the north of Ireland we can call ourselves what we bloody like because we can have either an Irish or a British passport and can choose to be whichever we like (and incidentally the number of people on an Irish passport is on the rise, regardless of beliefs, because it's deemed much safer to travel as an Irish person than a Brit at the minute). The full title is United Kingdom of Great Britain AND NORTHERN IRELAND because we are not part of Great Britain. Get it? Get your facts straight before you go mouthing off next time please.

reply

I'm sure I saw both Brosnan and Neeson give the Irish foreman a dirty look for his fake accent. On another note- they even gave Ned Kelly an Irish accent.

reply

Since when can Pierce Brosnan do an Irish accent? He might have been born in Navan, but he was raised in the south of England. If you want to hear his risible efforts, see the movie 'Taffin'.

It's also worth remembering that Pierce is technically an "American" actor, as he first found success in the USA with "The Manions of America". Playing, ironically, an Irish immigrant.

reply

They are both Irish and they are both great actors. Their accents are fine and I like the fact that their roles are always versatile. Great casting, really good movie.

http://pinartarhan.com/blog/

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]