MovieChat Forums > Lizzie McGuire (2001) Discussion > Lizzie McGuire or Hannah Montana?

Lizzie McGuire or Hannah Montana?


I would go more Lizzie McGuire...i grew up watching this show and can defiantly relate to it more. At least at that age. and miley cyrus is pretty annoying. what about you guys?


Buster: No mother, I can blow myself. You've interfered for the last time.

reply

i love them both. lizzie's my all-time favorite though. :)

Doctor that friend of urs what was her name?
Her name was Rose..
myworld=TWiCEasmanystars

reply

Lizzie McGuire. I grew up watching it too. I love the show Hannah Montana but I HATE Miley Cyrus.

Sir, just ask yourself...What would Jesus do?

Transformers

reply

[deleted]

Ya like "ya think?" OMG THATS SO FUNNY HAHAHAHHAHAHHA!...not

Mom:Dad fell off his wagon
Dyl:did he break anything
H.A.M.

reply

Lizzie McGuire. I think you cannot compare these two shows because Lizzie is an average girl while Hannah is a pop-star so, most of us will choose Lizzie over Hannah because Lizzie is most definitely relatable.

reply

Any girl can relate to Lizzie at some point in time, so I go with Lizzie McGuire.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
Abigail Chase: Look!
Ben Gates: It's a cipher...
Riley Poole: Clever!

reply

[deleted]

Lizzie McGuire. miley is definately anoying. she is a horrible actress, she was cute in the early episodes. that wore off fast. lizze had real issues people go through. let me have a hand count of how many girls reading this are secretly international pop stars? ohh yeah, none. :]

reply

[deleted]

Lizzie McGuire hands down. The characters were so loveable, and old disney was the best. It didn't have that annoying,fake audience laughter in the background. The storylines were better and it didn't include corny jokes. Hannah Montana is lame, and I feel bad for the the younger audiences of this generation who have to grow up with that

reply

lizzie mcguire i grew up watching the show and i liked it better than the newer shows like a lot of you say and i agree that it relates to me with lizzie being a girl just wanting to fit in with her classmates and get through life

reply

yep lizzie mcguire there is no arguing over it i mean c'mon most of us here on this board grew up watching lizzie mcguire,even stevens,etc..i was like @ 9 when it first came out and boy was i excited my room was all lizzie mcguired up and my birthdays were just the same oh and not to mention going to school dressed like lizzie,i remember everyone would say that i looked like hilary duff,i actually went to hilary's first concert,best day of my life!!!But yeh before the shows on disney were much more innocent and by that i mean they did not have lines like "you look like a tramp."*hannah montana*,get me,old disney was so much ever!

"Virgins are good for getting f(u)cked that's what im good for"-hilary duff,War,inc.

reply

I liked Lizzie McGuire because it was more real-i was such a dork like lizzie when i was a teen...still am.lol.

Hannah Montana is good for all those kids who are growing up with High School Musical and Suite Life of Zac and Cody. I'm a bit older so I don't like it as much...I liked Even Stevens!

*formerly pisanni_27*

reply

Lizzie McGuire!
I love that show!
But here the only times it's shown is during school hours and at 11:10pm :(

When Life Gives You Crayons, Colour Your World

reply

I grew out of Hannah Montana pretty fast b/c it got boring and really annoying, IMO. I was only in 3rd grade when Lizzie McGuire first started and it was much more realistic and relatable and what I grew up with. The serious moments were definitely tear-jerking and the comedic relief wasn't overly comedic. Oh and like Even Stevens, So Weird, The Famous Jett Jackson, Flash Forward, Naturally Sadie, Life With Derek and Phil of the Future, it didn't have a laugh track, which can be distracting for me. Heck, I even wanted to learn how to divide fractions after watching "Educating Ethan", lol. Lizzie McGuire wins in my book, so I don't think there's any comparison.

"Whatever toasts your bagel."
~Penny (The American Mall)

reply

LIZZIE MCGUIRE

Hilary is a much better actress then miley and Lizzie had a better cast, LM is also way more realistic then Hannah Montana.

reply

Lizzie McGuire, no question. Hannah Montana is okay, though I can't stand Miley Cyrus and I love Hillary Duff. But as an adult, I get sick to death of Hannah Montana when my Goddaughters watch it all the time, but I never got sick of Lizzie.

In fact, I'd say that's true of all the Disney shows. They used to be better.

Lizzie McGuire, Even Stevens, Boy Meets World, and Sister Sister were great shows. Smart Guy was pretty cute too.

Hannah Montana and Suite Life are cute, but I'm just sick to death of them. I can only take so much. Drake & Josh and iCarly are better, but I probably just haven't seen them quite as much yet. No doubt I'll be sick to death of them too, soon enough...

reply

You seriously can't be asking this question.
Not only are we in Lizzie McGuire forums but overall I think Lizzie mcguire Wins in an absolute landslide victory compared with Hannah Montana.
Too bad Disney did'nt fancy dipping a bit further into their overspilling pockets for a continued Lizzie McGuire series because I'm almost certain their profits would have been massive. Hannah montana is boring, turns people insane, has an absolute annoying way of trying to tell you when you're supposed to laugh with canned laughter because that was so hilarious I turn the TV off and played my pc. Lizzie McGuire all the way!

reply

[deleted]