MovieChat Forums > Jaws (1975) Discussion > Why did the Mayor care of anybody swam o...

Why did the Mayor care of anybody swam or not?


They’d already shown up. What difference did it make.

reply

I guess he thought that it looked unnatural for a beach to be filled with people and NOBODY goes into the water.

Weren't there reporters and cameras still around? They might've reported that Amity was a strange place. People are afraid to go into the water there.

reply

No, thats not it. The mayor wanted to go into the water himself but didn't want to go in alone, so he wanted the people in the ocean

reply

Then how come he didn't bring his bathing suit? LOL

reply

You kidding me? The anchor jacket is secretly a Vest of Swimming +4. He could have out swam Bruce and Michael Phelps combined.

reply

Love that anchor jacket! But the mayor smoked a lot. I wonder if he could've swum very far.

reply

It was in the car. He was going to go get it

reply

In the book by Peter Benchley one of the subplots was that the Mayor was into the mob for money via a holding company (or some such thing) and he desperately needed to keep the economy of Amity viable. That subplot, along with the one about Hooper having an affair with Brody's wife, was thankfully cut from the film script.

reply

Wasn't aware of that because I don't read books. By the way, is this book banned in Florida?

reply

LOL. If you are in Florida you had better read fast! DeSantis would likely consider the shark as a part of the woke crowd and want to ban him from Florida beaches.

The book by Benchley had some okay parts to it but the movie really was so very much better. They did well to scrap a lot of the story in the book.

reply

Movies are always better than the books

reply

50 years old and you write that? I'm sorry for your loss.

reply

That statement is just sad...

reply

If I read a book, I am forced to use my imagination. But if I watch a movie, I get to see it thru the directors point of view

reply

Fair enough...

reply

Plus, the director can be sure to remove any plot holes that may exist in the book before putting it to film.

reply

Thats a great point. Books always have more plot holes than movies

reply

I recall that the part describing Mrs. Brody's "glistening vagina" made quite an impression on my nine-year old self!

reply

I read the book as a teen, it made an impression on me. :)

reply

my kid read it, and he wanted to transition into a shark!

reply

LMAO! I guess they could do worse. Cleaner oceans in general I think, more protection for sharks, i would like to think slightly less pollution, and one would think that shark week has promoted more understanding of sharks. Plus, should be lots of food to be had, human or otherwise.

reply

smart!

reply

Why would the book be banned in Florida when the book setting is on an island off-shore of New York and the movie was filmed in Massachusettes?

You should read books. You might find your own imagination to be far superior to anything a director is able to put on screen.

reply

I agree with this. I can imagine future vacationers choosing a different beach to visit...remembering the shark infested waters of Amity they saw on the news.

reply

Hyperjet has it correct.

If news gets out that nobody is swimming, people are going to cancel their trips. The mayor wants the locals to get out there as an example. If the tourists perceive that the locals are comfortable swimming, they will follow.

So, its not business that day (though even that would be affected if people go home early because they aren't having fun), but future business that he is concerned about.

Author of the Sodality Universe
The Road from Antioch
In the Markets of Tyre
Flight to Lystra
The Theater at Ephesus
The Council on Jerusalem (coming 2023)

reply

Exactly. If people come to Amity and don't have a good time, they leave early or don't come back the next year, or go to the restaurants and complain loudly about how boring this place is and harsh everyone's buzz, and when they get home they tell everyone they know that Amity Island is boring and you can't even swim in the water. And the tourist economy takes a dip for that summer, and several years after.

New England tourist towns have a very short moneymaking season, a huge chunk of the town's population needs to make a year's worth of money in the summer and early fall, and if tourists lose interest in the town then they won't be able to heat their homes in the winter. I think the scriptwriters were right to change the mayor's motivations for denying that the shark was a threat. If a mayor leans on the chief of police to protect his own financial interests the chief of police defies the mayor, but if the mayor is worried about the economic survival of everyone in town... the chief of police can be persuaded. Bringing in the tourist-economy angle made for a better story overall.

reply

The Mayor was only concerned about tourism and the dollars it brings in.

reply

I'm only trying to say that Amity is a summer town. We need summer dollars.
Now, if the people can't swim here, they'll be glad to swim at the beaches of Cape Cod, the Hamptons, Long Island...

reply

That doesn't mean we have to serve them up a smorgasbord.

reply