MovieChat Forums > Olympus Has Fallen (2013) Discussion > White House Down or Olympus Has Fallen. ...

White House Down or Olympus Has Fallen. Take your pick.


Both are so similiar it's not even funny. Both have a good guy who is the eyes and ears while trapped in the white house. They are both NOT in the secret service, but want to be. Both save the president's life by beating the bad guys. Both of the movies have the White House under big time attack. Both have a plot involving nuclear weapons and killing millions of people. Both have a SEAL team in blackhawk helicopters that is sent to rescue the good guys and kill the bad guys, but the mission fails when the choppers get shot down. Both of the movies have a former good guy that turns bad, which sets up the plot. I could go on and on. So which was the better movie out of these? I guess i'll choose "Olympus Has Fallen" because of all the violence, with the mass shooting when the attack went down.

reply

Olympus Has Fallen over White House Down. They are both unrealistic but OHF is the better Action Movie. It reminded me little bit of "Air Force One".

reply

this kind of trash is rotting the brains of idiot americans

My Top 50 Films http://www.imdb.com/list/ls033211402/

reply

Spoken like a real buzzkill. Did you search this or did you somehow stumble over this thread?

reply

I was curious as to what kind of brain dead infantile idiots were fans of this nonsense. Truly, be proud of yourself, you are entertained by trash, how nice for you.

My Top 50 Films http://www.imdb.com/list/ls033211402/

reply

You call that curiosity to come to a movie forum for a action blockbuster which is obviously a non brainer and insult the persons who were entertained by that movie. Well I call that trolling. I have read my Kafka, Shakespeare, Eco and many many more. I have watched movies all my life. I have watched the independent intellectual ones, the brainless trash and everything in between. Why don`t you just pull the stick out of your ...?

reply

So, Mr. zguendogdu you claim to have watched brainless trash, are you purposely torturing yourself or do you enjoy brainless trash?

The medium of cinema is capable of achieving a higher level, it's a shame that certain studios and directors don't choose to attain that higher level. Thus films like this piss me off.

If they don't piss you off then I guess you are another fan of brainless trash.

reply

White House Down 5/10
Olympus Has Fallen 4/10

That answers your question. But neither are worth watching.



Example of senility.http://img638.imageshack.us/img638/2779/paintx.png

reply

Two films are certainly remarkably similar and you have listed some evidence to it. Now how about some differences as well:

- Olympus Has Fallen is a darker film. It has less humor, colors scale is literally darker and it has much more on-screen blood and guts. It takes itself seriously enough and although the whole film is fiction, it leaves the impression it *might* happen. White House Down is bit easier on the tone; it has more humor, more explosions, stunts and fun. It doesn't take itself too seriously and it follows the formula of a Bond film or Mission Impossible film.

- On that note, characters in Olympus Has Fallen are more greyscale, charismatic on it's own right, but characterized mostly through their job and position in Oval Office. They seam more like 'real' people. Even the villains are more realistic and even though they do have a leader, they are more of an amorphous mass, uniformed and compact. White House Down has more colorful characters, we know their quirks, good and bad sides and private matters. There are more character interactions. The villains are also more colorful and unique, each being recognizable among them.

- The relationship between the agent and US President in Olympus Has Fallen has been established from before; they are old friends and the agent has more personal investment in saving him. In White House Down, the agent and the President just met and their interaction is developing through the film. Also, the agent in OHF deliberately came to the White House after the attack to save the President, while the agent in WHD just happened to be there and went with the flow John McClane style.

- Also, big SPOILER:

- The villain in Olympus Has Fallen is revealed at the beginning and the tension is building on weather he succeeds in his plans and on who makes out of it alive. In White House Down, although mercenaries are present, the main villain is revealed at the end via twist.

I actually enjoyed both on different levels. They are quite complementary. Olympus Has Fallen is more of an action-thriller with elements of horror, while White House Down is more of an action film with elements of comedy, thriller and adventure. So, both work for me, depending on my mood. If I want something nail-biting, I'll pick Olympus, if I want more relaxed action, I'll pick WHD. Both are easily 8/10 for me.

reply

Olympus has fallen is definitely the better one. White house down doesn't leave mark on movie history while this film may actually become an action classic.

Olympus has fallen has actually a pretty tight script and you're on the edge on your seat all through the film. For me the film succeeds because it takes itself more seriously. It is certainly a darker experience as it tries to make you think: "could something like this actually happen?

And ofcourse the action scenes are masterfully crafted. The attack on white house is just thrilling to watch. secret service is trieing their best, but they're quickly outnumbered. Yet they fight to last man. Thats amazing to watch. '

Then later the whole cat & mouse gameplay inside the white house makes you recall die hard 1. Its that good. Without a doubt this is a modern action classic :)

reply