MovieChat Forums > Ôkami kodomo no Ame to Yuki (2012) Discussion > So what would you rate it out of 10?

So what would you rate it out of 10?


I want to see it badly it looks amazing but i'm curious to see what other's would rate it and why.

"Human kind can not gain anything without first giving something in return- Alphonse Elric

reply

I rated it a 10/10. I absolutely loved it. One of the best Anime films I have ever seen.

reply

I gave it 3/10 for the animation alone. I found the story extremely boring and slow paced.

reply

Pfft.. another White Racist, just like me.
You're just racist ! Admit it ! It lies deep within your heart ! Personally this is a great movie with such a terrific story, concept, and animation. yet I hate Asian cartoon. I gave it 1/10

reply

I gave it a 6.

The story was bland and too melodramatic.

The animation was "cartoonish", and the drawing looks lazy at times. The backgrounds and 3D scenes are very good, but the main characters are lacking life.

The ending was announced since the middle of the movie, so there were too many unnecessary scenes at the end.

reply

Haha.. another racist. It's not because the movie is bad, you're just a racist. Admit it ! I'm not alone here, I hate Asian cartoon, too..
I believe you gave Madagascar 8/10 because it was made by Americans ! Long live white people !

reply

1. I'm not racist.
You can't even imagine where I'm from, so that statement is null.

2. I don't hate Asian cartoons.
Some of my favorite directors are Asian, and I really admire the works of animators like Miyazaki, Otomo, Kon, etc. But this movie wasn't good.

3. I gave Madagascar 8/10 because it was well done. Not because is American.
I also gave 8 to Tokyo Godfathers, Perfect Blue and Howl's Moving Castle.
I gave 9 to My Neighbor Totoro, Spirited Away and Akira (those are really well done movies).

You can see a list of my entire ratings here: http://www.imdb.com/user/ur8136008/ratings.

4. I'm NOT white.

reply

8/10

reply

[deleted]