Is this the way people would REALLY act?
Just asking.
Many movies like this show everyone pulling together to survive.
This is human nature gone berserk!
Just asking.
Many movies like this show everyone pulling together to survive.
This is human nature gone berserk!
It depends a bit on the scale of the disaster, but mostly on the quality of the people themselves. Groups vary enormously in how they react to situations in which all external supports for moral behavior are removed. Look at how differently the Japanese and Haitians responded when their respective countries were ravaged by major earthquakes.
Closer to home, we can see how different groups handled the Katrina Crisis in Louisiana ten years ago. Traditional rural Whites were almost Japanese in the way they instantly pulled together to help each other, maintain order, and restore normal services. Meanwhile in New Orleans, the inner-city blacks acted, if anything, even worse than the Haitians did. In between these extremes were the responses of rural blacks and urban (non-traditional) Whites.
Excellent post. I wont even put my 2 cents in, it was done so well :)
shareYea none of that is true.But your're an example of how US media propaganda works.There was looting in Japan and natural disasters in US,Europe,etc.But Japan had less looting than you would see in other places because of social cohesion.Japanese police and news even reported looting. In US the culture is do what you want. But having lived in Japan you're more a representative of the group. If someone commits a crime then they pretty much ostracize the family.The flip side of that is there is blackmail and scams from people that threaten to report you for a false crime if you don't pay them compensation.You're not suppose to speak out on a lot of things and so forth. But if you're a foreigner they will go off on you.
But there will always be people that take advantage of disasters and people that help out. I lived in Louisiana near the Texas border during Katrina,Rita,etc.There were plenty of people that went down to problem areas and helped. Gave people that had their houses destroyed a place to stay. Even my family got things to send to people in disaster areas.But you also have people running scam funds,criminals,etc.Its like that everywhere.But the US justice report on New Orleans is 100% right. I've been down there and the most dangerous criminals are the law enforcement.They have had so many officers down there arrested for taking bribes,murder,drug trafficking,etc.
- Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by rulers as useful.
Yep most definitely. Japanese media would strive to maintain their stoic national character. The American media would only show certain races in a good light.
shareWhat a load of white supremacist bullshit. Black people were being raped and killed by whites in NO, whites were also committing crimes along with black people. Police raping black women and shooting civilians on site.
Same thing happened in Houston, ws groups travel to disaster zones to rape and kill.
I'm Chilean and lived the earthquake of 2010
the first thing that communications were lost, so were isolated, people who lived in buildings hurriedly came and met on the lower floors.
was Saturday and many people were at parties, all the people ran to see their families regardless of whether they have traffic lights and was dangerous
to lose connection with the rest of the world people met in small groups to pass the stress, until returned light and telephony.
people were saved or died in groups
chaos problems began to days later, at the response to shortages and theft
[deleted]
Sadly, I think so. When tragedy strikes, human nature goes out the window and survival rears its head, mostly only survival for self. The mob mentality is common and when a lot of people get hurt or killed by being forced to the ground and then others stomping/stepping on/kicking them just so they get to safety. A disgusting example of mob mentality (though not in the face of survival) is Wal-Mart on Black Friday when there have been injuries and fatalities. The Boston Marathon is a great example of pulling together to survive and how I hope I would/could react, but I've never experienced anything like that. I would probably freeze and curl up on the ground or something, in reality. Hopefully, I'll never know.
There's nothing human about taking the opportunity in a disaster/tragedy to steal, rape, torture, kill, etc., in the midst of people trying to survive. I never have and never will understand those "humans."
-Dad, who's that?
-Oh, that? One of my patients. He's...sick.
-Will he live?
-It's looking grim.
[deleted]
[deleted]
I had a problem with how the 'Fireman ' was potrayed in this film, he was fine and working as a team, helping the group to stay alive , and as soon as they saw he was a prisoner , he suddenly turned into a killer. Why? It just didnt make sense to me, Ok he has commited crimes in the past. But it's saying anyone who has been in prison will act like an animal like that gang when the chips are down. I thought it would have been better to still have him as a criminal, but that doesnt have to turn him into a serial killer the second he is discovered.
shareThe fireman was not a real one. He was an escaped convict like the others but had found a fireman's uniform and then had to act the part when others asked for help. Once he was alone with his victim he could revert back to his normal self.
shareThey were his saviors before his victims. Why wouldn't he give them up when the prison gang was a threat?
shareAs someone who has been in the middle of a chaotic bushfire, people tend to help each other and support each other-(within reason). When in an emergency situation and adrenaline is pumping. Many men and women just get stronger. It is hard to explain, but as someone who has always been a laid-back person, I felt something I have never felt before in that situation and was one of the loudest encouragers in the chaos. However, if we had escaped convicts on the loose as well in the middle of it all, then we would be less likely to help each other and more likely to only look out for ourselves. It's not fearing the elements that stops people from coming together, but rather fear of your fellow person that is the biggest threat in an emergency situation.
shareHe urges Pollo to kill the driver so that he could get out of the truck. He turns his back on the girl getting raped and urges them all to leave her. He leaves Pollo behind after he gets wounded. I didn't believe that he was a real fireman or that his intentions were pure from the very first scene.
sharewell, one instinct of human nature is to stick to the horde in case of emergency, so it is not so crazy that this group sticks together.
"laugh and the world laughs with you. Weep and you weep alone." - Dae-su Oh
Read up on 2010 Haiti earthquake. People were helping each other, and then the UN blue soldiers came in full riot gear pacifying hungry crowds with tear gas :/, crowds that were not hostile, but simply gathering near humanitarian aid cars.
Same thing with Katrina - you had cops shooting random people.
Rich west is scared *beep* of "angry mob" and build those myths and defense mechanisms against something that doesnt exist.
No, it's not how people would react. The news like to sell images of chaos and looters, but the facts are that in disaster situations pro-social behaviors tend to dominate.
share[deleted]