MovieChat Forums > Odd Girl Out (2005) Discussion > Does this really happen in USA?

Does this really happen in USA?


Im a 16 year old girl and i live in scotland, and i have to admit that the bullying that goes on in most of scottish schools is really nothing like whats shown in this film. Nothing is really schemed or planned by girls to bully other girls. Girls just tend to bitch behind eachothers back but be nice to the person in real life, and nobody really acts on what they say. Its only some girls that shout abuse at others, but nothing really on a large scale, and nothing so calculated as shown in this film!

Does this actually happen to people in America whats shown in this film?

reply

Unfortunetly yes it does really happen. I am ashamed to say so.

reply

Theres a lot of stuff that happens in North America that you wouldn't find in other places. Too bad really.

reply

Well, I dont know if you really want to hear my story, but Ill say it anyways. For some reason, (I seriously have no idea why), I was always picked on during middle school. People thought I was weird or would say mean things and definitely I was not a favourite of any of the popular girls. Anyways, without saying too much, I decided to apply to an academic highschool with a business and technology program in order to get away from all of these people in highschool (since I was determined I was not going to put up with it any longer). I actually excelled at the highschool I went to (all the people were really really nice and had a very pleasant high school experience) and went on to university. Im right now studying to be a engineer.

So without preaching too much... just remember, those girls or guys that pick on you at school will most likely end up becoming nothing. Middle school or highschool is their only moment to shine... but you'll have a lifetime.

reply

That's funny, this movie made me angry because I KNOW that it really happens LOL (in response to the person who said they get mad watching it because they didn't think stuff like this happened this badly)

It doesn't really matter if your fat, skinny, tall, short, black, white, wear glasses, have money, poor, whatever, someone who is insecure themselves, bored with life or have a rough home life is going to find something about someone they do not like and torture them. Then their friends who are so far stuck up their butt that they can't see straight wouldn't dare go against anything they say and go along with the bullying.

It's a sad situation because often times you will find that there are girls or guys that want to stick up for the person being bullied but are afraid to get involved because they don't want to be made fun of either. And teachers have so much else on their minds that often times this stuff happens right out in the open and they don't even NOTICE.

I was overweight, wore glasses and was the new kid in 7th grade. (LOL GREAT combo, eh?) There was this guy and his friend, they were both 8th graders. One day when the teacher left the room, they both decided to humiliate me and try and pick me up while I was sitting in my desk. They pretended to huff and puff and actually grabbed my arms and mooed. Now these days they would NOT have gotten away with touching me like that, but I, like most kids who are bullied did NOT want to make a big deal of it, because we know it brings on even worse torment. Well I couldn't help but cry about it when I got home and my mom, even though she said she would not, called the principle and had a meeting WITH the principle, the guidance councelor AND both of the kids! I was utterly horrified when I found out. Horrified. Well, let me tell you, it got THEM to stop..but it got their female friends to START and that was worse than the boys.

Everyday, as if she was stalking me, this one girl named Mandy would follow me around and call me "Bannana Boat" and lard ass and how she wanted to stab me with a fork to see if my tender fatty meat would fall off and all these other things. Then she would throw pebbles at me. There were teachers around but they were too busy chatting with each other. Then her friends would ask me questions like"How much do you weigh anyway? Your probably going to die and have never had sex. No offense but your pretty ugly..what parts of your body do you towel off first when you get out of the shower??"
It got to the point where I was terrified of going on combined 7th and 8th grade field trips for fear of having to sit near her and her friends or those boys on the bus.

In highschool she ended up being in my science class for a bit because she, surprise surprise, failed it the first time around. She asked me very, very politely if I would move over a seat so she and her friend could sit together. I, being stupid, scared and overly nice said sure, but the teacher said "Don't you dare" (Probably trying to get me to stand up for myself, and trying to tell me that I dont need to move just because SHE asked me to, but at the time, I was like you just sealed my fate dude.)so they had to sit at the back. Later I hear them say "Yeah, to bad the wooly mammoth couldn't move her fat ass so we could sit closer. I can't see the damn board. Guess i'm gonna fail again. Then I lucked out and she was in my gym class. She seemed to have a different target in that class though.

When I think about it, it wasn't as bad as the things that happened to the girl in this movie, but I think that I was lucky to have it just all of a sudden stop. That girl now works at a subway and is on welfare and has two kids and I hear isn't quite as bitchy as she was. The odd thing is is tht the guy who was a bully to me in 7th grade was in my jr english class and was perfectly pleasant to me. He had gotten quite heavy himself and I think that in alot of cases, age, appearance and what happens to you later in life really humbles you.

My younger sister dealt with some crap too. She was dating a guy, and they broke up, and he started dating this girl who would harass my sister in the halls, on the bus, over the internet, etc. Her ex got involved and started harassing her as well. This is sick but even the ex boyfriends drunk MOM would get on his im and message my sister and told her to stop being a bitch and stay away from her son (odd since all my sister would do is walk down the hall of the damn school, SHE was the one being harrassed. Damn clueless mom, just like the mother of the friend in this movie) One day my sister couldn't take it anymore and punched him right in the nose and they both ended up in the principles office. However, the principle let my sister off for it because he was aware of the harassment that was going on and he put a stop to it, which doesn't often happen.

After all that drama, the ex boyfriend moved away, and my sister actually made alot of friends and even joined cheerleading and became one of the captains and came out of highschool relitivly unscathed.

reply

Oh my gosh; this crap happens all the time. But I have never really experienced it to that degree first hand. Other girls that I've known have and I see girls that are treated that way all the time. I'll even admit that I've been one of the 'mean girls' at my school. But "I" have never been bullied so much and to that extreme in my entire life. I guess I'm lucky. I went to two seperate high schools. I transferred after my freshman year to a much smaller high school and wasn't exactly made fun of, but I was considered somewhat of a loner. Mainly bc I was still furious about the fact that I had to leave all my friends that I went to gradeschool/middle school with. So that year I was somewhat of an outcast, but I warmed up to it and now I'm actually very grateful that I did transfer. :)

It's unbelieveable that girls are out there planning on hurting other girls and ripping eachother to shreds over the tiniest issues. I'm thankful I've never experienced it to that level first hand, but it does happen and is very common. It sucks, but thats America for ya. Great example to put out there right?

So I ran into Su Chin & she's like "Hi, babies have fingernails."
-Juno.

reply

It's really sad that sometimes it actually starts at a really young age..you'll find that even in like first grade, so and so will be friends with so and so and then a new girl will come into the class who is instantly popular and will be jealous of the friendship that the two other girls have and try and manipulate one into only playing with her and dropping the other friend. Girls are deffinatly more vicious than boys. However, boys do their fair share..I remember seeing on the news about a little boy who had three best friends and then one year they just completly shunned him, for no good reason. They would make fun of him, not let him sit with them at lunch, gang up on him and make soccer practice and games a living hell for him, etc. He was only like 10 or so and tried to commit suicide.

I think that what this movie does is a good thing, because often times parents or the kids who are bullying or kids who are just kind of there in the hallway not wanting to get involved don't really see how it is effecting the person being bullied psychologically, and they think it's "just a little teasing." and they need to "grow a thicker skin". In fact I bet you that most of you that were bullied, your bullies do not even REMEMBER what they did or said to you, but YOU remember because to you, it was a big deal, at least at the time.

reply

Not if you beat their ass when they try to bully you the first time. All this suicide and crap is crazy. What happened to just beating up the bully?








Religion is regarded by the common people as true, by the wise as false, and by rulers as useful.

reply

I dunno, I thought that only happened in movies LOL

reply

this type of stuff was always happing at my school. there was alot of bulling at my jr high it got abnit better in high school but my school was very much populated by this type of mean girl types.

reply

I think there was more bullying in my elementary school honestly, but there was a lot in middle school too. Luckily this stuff never happened to me, and I have never been one to do the bullying. I have actually befriended a lot of those who are picked on and practically social outcasts and I've converted some of my friends to be the same way. I honestly feel like everyone should have a friend, and just because someone is unpopular that doesn't give you the right to treat them like crap. Anyway in my elem. school there was some really bad bullying. This one kid was bullied the whole time and instead of kooties we had "Bob" germs (his name was not Bob, but I omitted mentioning the real name). There was also this other girl who moved to our elem. school in 4th grade and was extremely picked on. She was even physically abused (I'm not sure if she was beat up, but some bad things happened to her). Anyway she had to switch classes because it became so bad, and joined our class. Me and my friends immediatley befriended her and let her hang out with us. I remember the first time we had recess and I was walking with her, and one of the girls from the other class took one of the balls and threw it at her head. She ran off crying, and it was really obnoxious. I felt terrible for her, but I'm glad that even when I was that age I was able to move past peer pressure and not care what other people think. It seems like after that year though she made more friends, and in middle school she had her own group of friends to hang out with (I was never in her classes after 4th grade).

There's bullies everywhere though and it's a shame. I was picked on a little because I had these pretty big glasses when I went to middle school, but only like once or twice. I am able to just shrug that stuff off because I know that if you just ignore it and don't react to it, most of the time they'll go to someone else to bully them. One of my friends got picked on all the time and I'm pretty sure it was because she would noticably get upset everytime. Anyway I'm a junior in high school now and one of my friend's is probably the most unpopular guy at school. Me and my one friend are truly like the only real friends of his. This girl at my lunch is incredibly mean and constantly says how he stalks girls and stuff (which is completely untrue, he has some pretty bad social skills, although he is extremely talkative, he just is bad at expressing things because he says everything he's thinking and he really wants a girlfriend so he asks a lot of girls out). Also, that girl who is mean I know for a fact was pretty badly picked on in the past (they said she was booed off the stage in 9th grade when she was saying her speech for Freshman Class President). I just don't understand how someone who was badly picked on is willing to pick on others. I mean she is mean about everyone, not just the unpopular kids now, but everyone. She's always badmouthing someone, and I've come to find her extremely annoying since all she seems to be able to do is say mean things.

Anyway yes bullying does happen in the US. It happens to some people more than others, but it happens. And that bullycide stuff is terrible! That just makes me want to be friends with those who are picked on more. I think everyone should think before they act. Even though I am friends with pretty much the most unpopular junior, my friend's are still my friends. Your real friends will not care about social standings and you shouldn't either. You can't help people being bullied if you're not even willing to be their friends.

reply

Yes, and I've never seen it get this bad, but it gets pretty bad sometimes. I go to an all girls private school, so... well most days are fine I suppose. I'm one of those people kind of on the fringes of high school society, so I don't know everything. But from my own personal experience I can tell you I know people driven to eating disorders and cutting because of public humiliation or being completely ostracized from a group.

I'm still a junior in high school, and even as I write this there's drama going on in my group right now. Everyone in my group doesn't like this one girl who insists on hanging out with us. We're not going to do insane things, but I don't know... I don't want to hurt anyone, but someone will get hurt. I hate it when these things happen and usually I stay out of it... It can get rough...

I keep telling myself that it'll blow over after we grow out of this teenage phase. That's what I look forward to whenever these things come up...

reply

no, it is not accurate at all. There is probably a case every 5 years or so of something like this happening, but seriously the characters in this movie are so deranged and unrealistic, this is EXTREMELY RARE, do not let this be your impression of America!

reply

yea, this is realistic.
Girls can be pretty evil.
In 5th grade, in a CCD class [[which is a religious class]] I had really long hair, and girls would throw candy, and gum and sweets into it, which i couldnt get out, I had to cut if off.My waist-long hair turned into a bowl haircut.
when I was in Middle School, people found out my dad died when I was younger, girls went around and called me a "Bastard" for weeks. [[cuz in the dictionary definition, thats what i was]] then another time Girls started calling me slut and, whore, and punk, just cuz most my friends were guys, and I dressed like one too. It got so bad that one day I was walking down the hall and some girl grabbed my hair and pulled me down to the ground saying thats where I deserve to be. I really hated middle school.

reply

Yes... unfortunately it does. A lot. I was targeted... a bunch of other kids were targeted... and I targeted some of the even uncooler kids because I had been targeted and wanted to look "Cool" ... but then of course I got called mean by the other kids who did the same thing.

I hated middle school... hated it and despised it with a passion. I would never want to go back. Kids are freaking evil. Words and jokes hurt like hell. I was lucky that once i hit high school, even though i had my issues, I found a niche that I felt safe in... and made some good friends. Our school was large enough that I could almost ignore all the *beep* from middle school. There were a couple of instances though, where i finally had it and told the teacher who basically told the guys who were doing it that if they kept it up they would be thrown out of summer school. (I was making up a class). Yeah, guys and girls were despicable... though in my case it was mostly *beep* guys...but believe me, there were girls that were just as bad.

I never did anything to them... I mainly kept to myself. I had a few good friends... I tried to be nice...though I wasn't perfect... but I was overweight, lacked a lot of self confidence and was an easy target.

reply

oh! it happens all the time! go on Youtube and you see girls beating the hell out of eachother for internet entertainment. My worst year was sixth grade. I had people threatening me, throwing things, saying stuff, and spitting in my face. it was horrible!

I don't want any more QUACKS running around in my head talking about my TOILET TRAINING!- Nuts.

reply

obviously from the previous posts yes it does happen here but it also happens in other places to. from what i've heard Japan is pretty bad when it comes to bullying but its different with each school. you are really lucky and to me you're also really privledged that you don't have bullying in your school. listen to "Hero" by Superchick. it's one of my favorite songs.


A person doesn‘t just wake up and stop loving somebody! Love is forever.-Buffy

reply

[deleted]