MovieChat Forums > Odd Girl Out (2005) Discussion > Are you serious? This movie is not reali...

Are you serious? This movie is not realistic AT ALL.


And I'm in high school.
This movie is garbarge and the farthest thing from reality.

reply

It's clear you were never bullied because this movie is extremely accurate. I was bullied in school and this is exactly how it was. People preying on you for no reason when you've done nothing wrong. People trying to tear you down and make your insecurities more insecure and make you want to hide your face. Alexa Vega did great portraying the "bullied" in this movie.

reply

No, this movie is very realistic! Bullying is very real and in our schools and kids really ARE that mean!

"I am gobsmacked"

reply



http://davidsask.wordpress.com/

The acting was good but man the ending was so *beep* whack bad and would never happen,said resolution so fast. The principal never got the kids to tell truth is also suspect, also website created by teens really and not brought up again?! I also question the parents still being civil to each other after said incidents esp if small town!

reply

High school was VERY brutal. I learned to grow up, HAD to.

reply

All you who are saying that this movie is ridiculous and bullying like this doesn't happen are majorly delusional. Let me tell you I know FIRST HAND that things like this most defiantly DOES HAPPEN! I lived it, teenage girls are hideous and they don't back down they are dirty, ugly and relentless. Not only did I live this but I see it ALL THE TIME because I work in a high school, I see it ALL THE TIME! So I don't know what planet you are all on but it ain't earth

reply

Same thing basically happened to me, but in grade nine. I went to a Kindergarten to grade 8 school, and most of us were pretty close. I had a close group of friends, girls and guys and we stayed friends all summer before grade nine and the first couple months of grade nine. I was really ugly when I was younger (I still am not beautiful, probably about average, but definitely not as awkward as when I was younger) and so I started to get picked on about that.

A couple of the girls in my group of friends started to hang out with the popular group, and the popular group wanted nothing to do with me because of the way I looked. At first they just started telling people that I followed them around. I heard the rumors, and I got the hint and stopped hanging out with them. It hurt though since they had been my best friends. Then for some reason, the rest of my group except one turned on me as well. They started the whole "She follows us around" thing as well. So I stopped talking to them as well.

And then the teasing started, they all started calling me an ugly loser all the time. I got messages on MSN messenger from my friends about how ugly I am. So I blocked them. They sent me emails and talked about how ugly I am through the emails. So not only did I have to deal with being made fun of for being ugly at school, but home as well. I tried my hardest to look good, but it didn't matter. I wasn't overweight (although later I did let myself go because of it) but my face was.

By the end of ninth grade I was depressed and had no one except the one girl from my group of friends. I spent a lonely summer by myself after grade nine, and then I started grade ten and I met a new group of friends. But my old group still bothered me, and that's when I did start gaining weight, because I was depressed. So I ended up being both overweight and ugly.

Eventually in grade eleven though, I just decided to ignore them. I spent the first two years of my High School being bullied and my grades and everything were bad because of it. But in grade eleven, I realized I only had two years left to bring up my grades and to enjoy school. But they seemed to have either out grown bothering me, or they just didn't care anymore by that point. I rarely heard any ugly jokes in grade eleven or twelve.

And then after High School I decided to smarten up and lose the weight I had let myself gain. I am now thin again and I think I've grown into my looks. A few years ago, one of the guys who made my life a living hell actually asked me if I wanted to go out sometime. I of course turned him down. I don't care if he's grown up by this point (we're 27 now) he wrecked my self-esteem completely. He was one of my main tormentors. He was worse than the girls were. So even if I am friendly with him now, I will never date him.

The other girls talk to me now, and I talk to them but there is still the one girl who still hates me. The rest have apologized but she just can't seem to let it go. I live in a different city now than the town I grew up in and whenever I go down to visit family, and we bump into each other she is rude. She tells me I am still an ugly pathetic loser in her eyes. Which doesn't make sense to me. We're only 27, and she's had three divorces and four kids with different guys. She is currently living at home with her parents. While I've actually made a living for myself, and yet I am the pathetic one. I've pointed this out to her, but she doesn't seem to want to hear. I've never met anyone who can't seem to move past High School like she her. Most people I know move on, but from what people tell me, she is still a major bully. I don't get it. She's supposed to be a mother.

reply

If you mean the ending, then yes, it's very unrealistic that a victim would stand up to their tormentors and everyone would cheer them on.

I was about the same age as the girls in this movie when it first came out and during bully awareness week, they made us all watch it in school. Bullying actually got worse during that week because a lot of my peers thought it was "awesome" that those girls pushed Vanessa to suicide and they thought everything that happened to her was validated because she "wasn't cool enough" to be in the popular clique in the first place. Not even kidding.

reply

It's not unrealistic that someone would stand up to their bullies, especially after the point that Vanessa got to, nor was it unrealistic for some students, esp at the encouragement of a friend, would applaud her; most kids like it when people stick up for themselves.

reply

Sorry, I forgot that's only instances where physical abuse is going on that victims generally won't try to stick up for themselves. As for the cheering, I guess I can't speak for all instances, but at the school I went to, any cheering that happened was when the bullies were beating up their victims.

reply

No problem. Kids can be rotten, but most are decent enough to appreciate someone who sticks up for themselves, plus you know, it was a moment of good insults being delivered; they can usually be counted on for that.

reply

Actually this is possible, I heard stories like this and its so sad!!!!

reply