I actually think this is the order from best to worst...
4
2
1
3
1 and 2 are pretty give or take but I really liked 4 the more I watch it. The 3rd is by FAR the worst.
American Wedding is my favorite AP sequel. The entire movie is hilarious and sweet at the same time. American Pie 2 was very funny but it was very similar to the first movie. I enjoyed Reunion. But I'd have to go 1, 3, 2&4 are tied.
shareDefinitely the weakest out of the 4, It feel's like the Stifler stand alone film rather then about Jim and his friends. For me, when Stifler isn't front and center of the American Pie films is when they are great, he's good in small doses. 4th for me gets stronger and more likeable as time goes on, Part 2 is a solid fun sequel and I love that film for the Jim and Michelle romance been blossomed. Wedding just doesn't feel like a American Pie film, as I said it feels like a Stifler stand alone with the other's popping up here and there. Poor Thomas Ian Nicholas as Kevin, might as well have not been in the film as much as they gave him in Wedding. I can see why Chris Klein turned it down.
1. 1
2. 2
3. Reunion
4. Wedding
From best to worst for me:
American Pie
American Wedding
American Pie II
American Reunion
I think "Reunion" is the worst. Not bad, but kind of stale.
share