Even though the means are different, like it or not but Hitler and socialists sought ultimately the same social end (if not economic) of a homogenous world.
That is straight-up bullsh!t. Socialists seek a borderless world of equals, not a world forced to be culturally homogenous. And if you look at the socialist countries of the 20th century, you see that a large part of their project was anti-colonialism, anti-imperialism and national self-preservation. Almost all of the socialist countries of the 20th century were born out of anti-colonial rebellions, wanting to be independent and preserve their own cultures and not be dominated and have others impose their own way of life upon them. It's only since socialism has been overthrown and they've all gone capitalist that they've been swallowed up into the uniform Americanized corporate McCulture that now dominates the world from one corner to another, their markets flooded with the products of American capital overwhelming their way of life. When Eastern Europe was communist, their countries had thriving industries in film, literature, music. Those have now been overwhelmed as Hollywood, with its greater resources that few can compete with on the world market, has flooded in. The once-thriving Soviet film industry, which churned out more classic films than most other countries, has been replaced with the typical low-quality soulless junk we have in the West, where profit is king and quality comes second. It's capitalism that's creating a homogenized global culture, one modeled after the dominant capitalist country, the US, whereas socialism had a lot of countries with their own unique cultures, thanks to their closed non-market economies that Western capital couldn't penetrate.
In fact, one of the last countries in the world that doesn't blend into this universal McCulture is North Korea, a socialist country, which places a heavy emphasis on preserving their independent Korean identity as compared with their thoroughly Americanized southern neighbors. That doesn't mean they believe in completely cutting themselves off from the world (contrary to popular myth), or that they hate the rest of the world, but that they have a closed market that isn't completely flooded with Hollywood movies and all other things American, that they don't feel they have to Americanize to be a modern society. They're one of the last countries in the world that's actually unique in the way that you're talking about (though not exactly, since they're socialist rather than feudalist).
Socialists want a world of independent equals, not a world with one culture imposed on all the rest. Hitler wanted a more extreme version of what the US has actually imposed on the world (only the US imposed its culture on top of already-existing cultures, whereas Hitler wanted to completely erase already-existing cultures to make way for his own).
If Japan remained isolationist, I guarantee it would have been an even more fascinating country today, the source of much world admiration.
If Japan remained isolationist, the West would have broken its doors down eventually and then it would have been colonized and today it would be even further from your romanticized conservative ideal than it already is. That almost happened anyway. Really they were incredibly lucky that they hadn't been taken over and colonized already, because they would have been helpless to resist if any of the Western imperialist powers decided they really wanted to take over Japan. Japan changed its course after the US forced it to open its markets to American trade, threatening military attack if they wouldn't. The disparity of power forced a realization on a section of Japan's ruling elite that Japan was doomed unless it scrapped the feudal system, industrialized and capitalized, and joined the imperialist club so it could become a strong country that the West couldn't impose its agendas on. The feudal system was outdated and holding Japan back, and it had to either modernize or perish entirely. The people who realized this were, in fact, samurai, who realized the samurai's day was done because feudalism couldn't compete with Western capitalism. Japan needed to compete to stay alive, or it would have been swallowed up entirely and become a colony.
Sig under construction
reply
share