I don't believe I would. After first watching this movie, I was kinda mad at her for not taking it because HELLO! JESSE TUCK?! Who wouldn't live forever if she had the promise of being loved by him? But then I started thinking about it, and if she had drunk from the spring, her life wouldn't have been normal. She would have experienced marrying and watching her children dying along with her husband...and since she would live forever, she would watch that happen over and over and over again. Unless she got the first family she had to drink from the spring, and then what would Jesse come home to? A married Winnie, husband, and kids. So....then what would Jesse and Winnie do? Exactly. She wouldn't be with Jesse forever, but she got to be with him that summer, and she got to live her life. The way it's supposed to be. I'd take that over anything.
reply
share