Your only real criticism here is the story. I will not accept being aimed more at children to be a valid criticism as it does not make a movie comparatively lesser in terms of quality. And the score is extremely subjective and generally not that important to most viewers unless it is downright obnoxious. I've never heard anyone complain about it, so I guess our anecdotal evidence is equal on that account. And as to the characters, I don't really see reason to address such a nonspecific claim of one set being 'better' than the other - I can't possibly determine what you might mean by that as I see nothing wrong with either set of characters.
In terms of the story, if you really want to quibble about the best Miyazaki movie (and really I think this is a stupid conversation to be having as all the films I have seen were excellent in their own ways, with the exception of Ponyo which just wasn't as good), then it isn't Mononoke, but the earlier Nausicaa of the Valley of the Wind, which thematically is superior.
But as I said, a silly argument to be having. Also, I should note that the above discussion was objective. Subjectively, Spirited Away probably is my favourite for personal reasons - it is responsible for my introduction to and love of anime. I saw the trailer for it on television long before I was able to see the entire film, but just that small segment intrigued me and opened up my mind. It therefore occupies a special place for me. I mean, for the same reason in the world of science fiction I will always love the original Star Trek above all other Star Treks that exist and will exist - it is certain (and Mr. Spock will always be my favourite).
reply
share