I don't understand why people are showering this film with praise. I've never seen a film so manipulative of it's audience. It was basicaly saying "Life is *beep* and the only way you can make things better is by making other people feel REALLY bad and guilt tripping them into helping others." The kid dying at the end was totally unecessary and served only the purpose of making the audience feel really bad. The narrative was so bad you could almost hear the plot threads cluncking together. It tried to deal with everything that's *beep* in the world: death, drug addiction, spousal abbuse, bullying, alcoholism, theft, descrimination against deformed people and paedophilia. But rather than actually dealing with these inteligently the director decided to throw every cliché about these issues into a big kleenex box and stir up for about 120 minutes with a big wooden spoon.
Never before have I actually felt violated by a movie. It wasn't just that it was a bad movie. It was the lack of subtlety with which it tried to make me feel sorry for the characters. The kid dying at the end felt like the ending of American History X (not a terrible film) where the kid was clearly killed simply to make you think "yeah, rasism is bad. If I'm a rasist I'll end up getting shot. Even if I repent after being a rasist". I feel as if this film raped me somehow. It didn't seduce me into a fit of genuine tears with subtle dialogue and good characters meeting a distressing ending. It simply pinned me down and clumsily tugged at my heart strings while screaming "cry bitch".
Fire! Fire! Fire!
reply
share