Was the curbstomp wrong?

I like to think that the curb stomp was wrong, totally wrong, he was unarmed and defenseless, however, it's not totally unjustified, the way I look at things the matter of degree never come into question when the attacker understands the ramifications of his actions. He knew if they went to steal his car, there would be trouble, that's why they were armed. They knew they were risking their lives and they did it anyway. It's obvious Derek is a dangerous guy, very obvious, but they acted anyway.

I once saw an interview with a guy in prison. He killed a man with a box cutter because the man had not repaid him for a soda he bought him. He looked at the camera and told them, he asked nicely to be repaid, the man cursed him out and told him he didn't owe him a a *beep* thing, blah blah blah. Killed him with a box cutter, know how long you got to try to kill someone with a box cutter? Then he asked the guard, now whose fault was that, his or mine?

She tried to sit in my lap while I was standing up.

I won't deny, the "curbstomp" was gruesome and perhaps excessive. However, when I first viewed the film I didn't find it completely unjustified. That was, until, Norton stood up in the street and faced the cops. The look of pride on his face chilled me to the bone and helped me to realize how unlike him I am, and how disturbing it is that I considered his actions to be rational. In conclusion, I'm unsure of what I'd do, but I'd undeniably be very pissed. No one should rule out the possibility of curbstomp. You never really know what you'll do in such a situation until it comes along.

Last Movie Watched:
Cache (Hidden): 9/10

The first time I saw it I was shocked but was also like, yeah, take that bitch. Come to my house with guns with my family here, especially with a baby. But realistically, it was the wrong thing to do (the curbstomp) but there was a pretty clear hatred towards black people too and his father was murdered by a black fella too, so I reckon that had a pretty big impact for coming up with the curbstomp, probably a feeling of self justice! I don't think I could do the curbstomp over someone stealing my car. It works well with his character though, no mercy!

Curb-stomping was pretty *beep* up, only a sick maniac would make someone put their teeth on the curb like that and then kick their head in. Even if they were murdering thieves.

I said I never had much use for one....never said I didn't know how to use it.

Yes it was completely wrong, yeah the guy tried stealing his car. But curb stomping someone is just down right inhumane.

in an individual becoming judge, jury and executioner?



The sun shone, having no alternative, on the nothing new. Samuel Beckett

200% deserved. Theft and assault for no good reason deserves harsh punishment and trash like those have no place in our society, nor in a prison eating from our taxes and burdening mankind.

So if you saw someone trying to steal your car, which is probably worth a few to a few dozen thousand dollars, you would curbstomp them? Really? You would try and kill them? Over a theft that is hopefully covered by your insurance? You would risk your morals, your freedom, and your immortal soul (if you believe in that sort of thing, which I do), over a car? Please, tell me you aren't serious. Or else claiming that this movie is one of your favourites is really strange, because you obviously didn't watch it.