This show was definitely a mixture of excellent, mediocre, and terrible episodes. Most of the terrible episodes were the incredibly lame "clip" shows which simply recycled old footage and, in many cases, changed the plot of the original clips! That totally annoyed me!
Anyway, let's focus on the good. Here's a list of my favorite episodes, split up by seasons:
SEASON 1:
Quality of Mercy: Everyone seems to love this episode, and I agree. The "twist" ending was great, as was the entire premise. This was also one of the few good episodes that also had a top-quality sequel following it.
The rest of Season 1 didn't stand out, in my opinion. However, honorable mentions go to "Sandkings" and "The Conversion".
SEASON 2:
Stich in Time: My third-favorite episode of all-time. Combined a great premise (time traveler killing convicted murderers BEFORE they can commit their crimes) with interesting characters. Even the side story (nerdy investigator's unrequited love for his colleague) worked well. Unfortunately, this episode spawned a lousy two-part clip show called "Final Appeal", which aired 4 years later.
The Deprogrammers: Depressing episode, and the plot was a bit campy and simplistic. However, somehow the episode worked, and was one of the more memorable ones. The ending was a surprise, and I liked it depsite being a downer.
The Light Brigade: I saw this BEFORE Quality of Mercy, and I still loved it. This is the only sequel episode that I really enjoyed. Again, a downer ending, but most fitting. I hope that earth isn't so intellectually, physically, and strategically outmatched if we ever end up in an interstellar war!
The Refuge: My favorite episode. It's definitely weird, but the main character shares the viewer's confusion. This was one episode where I was happy to see the hero triumph!
Honorable mentions: Worlds Apart, Trial By Fire, Vanishing Act
SEASON 3:
The Camp: Uplifting underdog story. Sadly, the happy ending was somewhat ruined by the boring and preachy "Promised Land" sequel that followed in a later season.
Heart's Desire: A fun Western theme with a supernatural twist.
Honorable mention: Dead Man's Switch, Feasibilit Study
SEASON 4:
No episodes stood out as "best", in what I feel is this show's weakest season.
SEASON 5:
Tribunal: Being Jewish, this episode was especially meaningful to me. The ending was particularly satisfying and emotional. This was the best of the Alex Diakun time travel episodes.
Honorable Mention: Small Friends, Blank Slate
SEASON 6:
Gettysburg: Almost as good as Tribunal, this Alex Diakun time travel episode delivers. The President who gets shot on inauguration day in 2013 is surprisingly similar to Barack Obama. Strange!
Something About Harry: Third Rock from the Sun's Joseph Gordon-Levitt stars as an amateur teenage detective, trying to figure out what his mysterious neighbor is up to. The surprise ending appears to be a downer, but leaves you with a positive feeling in the final seconds. Well done overall, and overlooked by nearly everyone posting in this thread.
Honorable Mention: Manifest Destiny
SEASON 7:
A New Life: My second favorite episode. Keeps you in suspense, and surprisingly believable. The downer ending is fitting, as the hero's triumph would seem unlikely given the circumstances.
Think Like a Dinosaur: One of the more emotional episodes, this fan favorite was very well done.
Abduction: Obviously inspired by the Columbine shootings, this is something every teenager should watch.
Honorable Mention: Flower Child, Family Values, Patient Zero
reply
share