Based on the assembly that is as close to a directors cut as we are likely to see, I don't think anything went wrong. This film is just a totally different take on the ideas. Alien was one thing (horror movie on a spaceship). Aliens was another thing (Military action film with monsters). Alien3 is a brutal, nihilistic horror film, and a perfect place to end the series. Good thing they didn't make any more.
It was a good film your right. But it wasn't special.
The ending is awful. People hated that scene. So bad...they made another film trying to salvage the absurd sad, sad ending.
They never did.
Both films flopped.
Still, good art design. I liked the weird CGI. The score was good. Weaver being back was awesome. Fincher was a great pick in 1992. Was that the year MTV peaked before the Internet? But nobody ever knew who was in control.
And the blame for the financial failure was passed.
But the script was awful! You could throw 50 million dollars into a pile of dog shit...and then it becomes a pile of worthless dog shit once valued at 50 million dollars but now just shit.
Only the fringe fans of the Alien series can truly appreciate it, like myself.
What was bad about the ending?
Who hated it, who is "people"?
I am also people, and I liked the ending. I think it made perfect sense and was quite poetic.
If you thought a series like Alien would have a happy ending... you weren't paying attention! xD
At least Ripley got to go under her own terms and achieved her goal of the company not getting their hands on the xenomorph.
So instead of answering that one relevant question, you instead decided to sarcastically answer the one that was less relevant and obviously pointing out that there are also people that adore that movie for it's strong points.
I know, hence I said: "you instead decided to sarcastically answer the one that was less relevant and obviously pointing out that there are also people that adore that movie for it's strong points."
What went wrong was no Hicks and no Newt. The audience didn't like that their characters were killed off. I'm sure it would have went over much better had they been in the movie. Even if Hicks was killed by the alien during the movie. Not having those 2 important characters pissed the audience off.