MovieChat Forums > Triumph des Willens (1935) Discussion > Don't think of the Nazis as 'evil'

Don't think of the Nazis as 'evil'


Before I get death threats let me clarify my statement. When we think of Nazis today we think of them as we do the neo-Nazis and other openly racist groups: bunch of hateful, ignorant, white trash hicks. The fact is that the Nazis were hateful, but they were far from ignorant. Many of them were highly cultured people: Doctors, Lawyers, Businessmen, etc. I'm sure if you were to meet one at a dinner party they'd be very charming. There is no way the German people, or any people for that matter would follow people that had "evil" personalities. While I was watching this film the hairs on the back of my neck stood up. Why? Because it's mesmerizing, and I'm saying this as a black man from Arkansas. I can see why so many followed these people. They didn't do it because of the hatred of the Jews, but instead because they had an excessive pride of their own culture and country. My point is we need to stop thinking of evil in terms of something we can spot a mile a way. True evil tricks you. True evil comes with a charisimatic smile.

reply

One thing that is said is that the Nazi's were supported by very many 'good' people.

reply

Who cares if they were evil? What dressers they were! Oy vey!

reply

great post.

chesterton said exactly the same thing about evil. (via his detective-priest character Father Brown - the Father Brown stories have many profound observations - confusing mixed up with lot of roman catholic propaganda) [chesterton's blindness towards fascism proper is another topic - not germane to this discusion - Orwell has covered that in his famous essay 'notes on nationalism'.]

While on this: this film as 'pure film' (art for art's sake types take note!) deserves 10/10. So I will *not* rate it - as many others haven't as won't.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Real life people aren't just "evil". There are no mustache-twirling, black-hat-wearing villains in reality. Most people who do "evil" do so because they're convinced they're doing the right thing.

By demonizing Hitler as an evil monster, you kinda lessen the impact of his crimes. He wasn't an otherwordly monster, he was a human being. That thought is actually more frightening: That a simple human being could be capable of such horrific crimes against humanity.


S.

reply