Sylar or Spock?

He is horrible as Spock.

He seems really stupid to me, dull, and he's gay on top of it.

I don't think he has what it takes to play Spock.

Spock is a COMPLEX character who is alien and part human. He tries to be the best Vulcan ever, because he is part human, and does a great job. But, he battles with that. He is also SUPER SARCASTIC when he should be completely logical. He is also extremely witty, when he should be dull, but he hides it all so you have trouble telling.

He is also a passionate friend and relentless person when it comes to helping everyone out.

He's a great character and this guy plays him like he's on meds.

Sylar

Sylar. His hair was far better in that role.

Sylar, it was a career defining role.

Didn't know he was a gay. I'm currently watching American Horror Story: NYC and he plays a gay character in it. That should have been a clear sign enough. Do they have guts to cast heterosexuals for gay roles anymore?

Spock.

He was great as both, but he was absolutely perfect as Spock, so I'm going with that one.

Sylar.