MovieChat Forums > Elliot Page Discussion > Why is this page still trending?

Why is this page still trending?


He is a dude. Get over it.

reply

Translation: "My opinion means more than yours. Get over it."

reply

opinion? Its a fact that he is a dude. He knows better than you and me i think

reply

opinion? Its a fact that he is a dude. He knows better than you and me i think


You clearly don't.

reply

.... and this is exactly why this page is still trending.

reply

Is it fact? Here is a transgender person who says that they are not fully male:

https://twitter.com/BuckAngel/status/1254852427959816192?s=19

reply

Finally someone who makes sense. He doesn’t deny that he was born a woman.

Notice he still calls himself transsexual not transgender which is now acceptable term.

When and why did transsexual became offensive and replaced with transgender?

Wouldn’t it make more sense that a person who didn’t have any surgery and hormones but is living as a gender not assigned at birth be called transgender and the person who had surgery and everything is called transsexual?

Was just thinking, if it is just about gender, that is social construct and it is not biological then there wouldn’t be need for reassignment surgeries (or as they used to say sex change) and no need to take hormones, I know some of them don’t do it as they feel comfortable as they are or don’t have the funds.

I was just reading a bit of this course on Gender and Sexuality https://courses.lumenlearning.com/suny-culturalanthropology/chapter/gender_and_sexuality/

There are some points in there that I have questions about.

Shouldn’t still some biological sex diferrences be considered natural and not cultural? I gather from reading this course that most things we think as natural are actually cultural. Is the term sex or biological sex obsolete?
What is wrong with biological determinism? I know we all don’t want to conform to our gender roles, e.g. women stay at home and make babies, and that is fine, there are too many people as it is. But are we so evolved from nature that procreation is not important factor regarding sex and reproductive system distinctions? All or most beings (especially mammals) procreate in similair way, they all have the instinct for survival of their species, and they all or most have sex distinctions. Most of the time there is male and there is female in most species, even plants.

To be continued...

reply

I know there are some fishes who change sex (gender?!😅🤔), male seahorses carry babies, some female insects like praying mantis are bigger than their male counterpart and they eat them after sex. So is biological sex of animals too biological or is it cultural as we assigned them to be male or female or intersex? Or this only applies to humans? Should we now only talk about distinctions of male and female in gender terms only and sex only for sexuality? Am I understanding this correctly? It seems sex distinction as terminology is not in use anymore.

Sorry for the TLDR and if what I wrote made no sense, I am quite bad at expressing myself in my language let alone in English.

reply

There was another tweet where the same person said that they are sick of transgender people telling non- transgenders that they are transphobic because they don't think they are the gender they transitioned to. He says that transgenders who believe they are the gender they transitioned to are what make people hate transgenders because they are in denial.

Your English is good. What's your first language?

reply

Yeah, he has a point.

I am quite accepting of Trans folks (I just can’t wrap my mind on non-binary people) and I also think that it is stupid to call someone transphobic if the only thing they disagree with them is that they are not natural/biological women or men but otherwise support their personal freedoms.

And I am left leaning ideologically but there are more and more things I don’t agree with and find crazy. Like cancel culture, and if you have slightly different opinion than others you are a bad person.

As a character from my favorite tv show would say: Political correctness gone mad!” 🤪

Thanks for the compliment, I try. 😅Spellcheck certainly helps but it is difficult sometimes to think of the appropriate words so I need to concentrate more, especially when writing about some serious subjects. My first language is Croatian.

reply

The only "fact" is that SHE says she's a dude. That's not the same as actually being one. You've confused the word fact with the word declaration, but they are not synonymous.

reply

He is clearly a dude, only dinosaurs lack the capacity to understand the higher plane of existence that is transgender.

reply

One is not a dude simply by saying it. No more than saying "I am a hamster" means you became one.

She is still all woman. A woman just pretending to be a man. It's not the same thing.

reply

Then I am your landlord. You admit I know better than you or anyone, and who are you to question it

It was the first of the month few days ago, waiting on the rent mate....

reply

" Its a fact that he is a dude."

I don't think that word means what you think it does.

reply

Because Elliot is trans and transexuals are the future.

reply

A transgender is not a transsexual.

reply

Trending in the news cycle, just in general, is the goal.

reply

men are perverts, Eliot is a pervert, he is like many men... excited & aroused just by the mere thought of other humans thinking & talking about his genitals.... it is the center of the conversation & good ole Eliot is masturbating with feverrish delight knowing so many internet nerds and basement-dwellers can't get his sexuality out of their minds, & wondering so thoughtfully on what his genitals might look like

reply

"Eliot is masturbating with feverrish delight"

link to the video?

reply

yes! thank you for saying something original!

I dont agree with it, but shit well done!

Thank you for proving to me some people have some original thought

reply

Because its Elliot's page! :D got it? Haha

reply

a creepy dude, that's way

reply

the OP or Eliot?

reply

Well it is a debate between Rhodes and Fulbright therapist that she has a irrational passive regression against something. The common intersecting point is Gal Gadot starring in Wonder Woman 2 and possible 3 movie. That is something Juno never got a sequel so this is her way hiding that fact.

reply

Because this is the Elliot Page.

reply

nice

reply

It is pretty much objective (dna, biology, etc) that she is NOT a dude.

Get over it.

reply

[deleted]

i always only had A ;)

let me ask you a question, mister biologist. you know what a man and a woman can have? that's right, kids.

you know what she and her wife can never have? you guessed right: kids ;)

because ... biology

reply

Touché!

reply

[deleted]

Who said anything about getting a room? All I said was "Touché!" You're projecting your homosexual tendencies into the conversation.

reply

I'm the sheriff around here and you need to stick to the topic at hand

Making personal attacks just weakens your credibility to not make any point whatsoever

reply

That reply ☝

👍

reply

[deleted]

'cause your fonts aren't cringe at all. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

reply

[deleted]

Oh dear... you are serious ! Sorry. I didn't know.

(as if I cared, hahaha) 😅🤣😂

🖕🖕

💋

reply

[deleted]

Hi its the sheriff again

This stupid text/font doesn't make you original

I have spoken

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

So that's why you're here?

reply