Canadian schools burn thousands of books considered politically incorrect

We should be teaching why the message is wrong, rather than trying it to cover up and erase it.

That's the key element. But... what if such wrong message wasn't there in first place?

Asterix and Tintin were my favorite comics when I was a kid. I had the full collection. And yeah, there was a lot of stereotyping, but it was background decoration, like the French guy with a striped shirt and an Accordion in American movies. On the other side, the main characters in the plot were layered and balanced. It was nowhere close (to compare) to modern media which divides main characters into (1) good guys belonging to some ethnic group/gender, and (2) evil or stupid guys belonging to some other ethnic group/gender (aka white dudes).

If the original content is easily available, people can do some checking. Once you erase or ban the original content, you can say that the message was whatever you want and it will stick.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

This just screams of white folk (and yes, I'm white too) not being able to put their hands up and say "sorry, our ancestors fucked up".

I dont think the idea is to purge all evidence of these books from history , its to get them out of classrooms

People make the same point when someone says
"Hey perhaps we shouldnt have this statue (e.g. Cecil Rhodes) up in the town square
someone else:
"but its our history , to forget is to not learn and repaet mistakes"

Which is all fine , you record the history - but once we've figured out, 300 years later , that invading entire continents , pillaging the natural assets , enslaving the population, and ruling over them isnt all that cool .

you dont celebrate the perpetrators of this in the same way.
To leave them as a statue , in a city centre ,on a plinth that says "Here is cecil Rhodes - our hero who slaughtered thousands to bring new african countries into our portfolio of stolen countries"

is taking the piss a bit isnt it?

TLDR:
Remeber , record , sure , but you dont have to "celebrate"

reply share

add reply

formatting help

You're obsolete. Go away.

reply share

add reply

formatting help

Ah, the poetic irony of burning Fahrenheit 451. They can have my copy of it for their bonfire of insanities.

Leftists, Right-wingers is such a simplistic way to label everything, as if all people are divided into two distinct political teams. Most folks with common sense are dotted across the long stretch of this wide divide.

reply share

add reply

formatting help