MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > What are some movies you consider “Perfe...

What are some movies you consider “Perfect Movies” and what does that mean to you?


To me, a perfect movie isn’t necessarily my favorite movie, but rather a movie that perfectly accomplishes its goals. A movie where I can’t think of a way to genuinely improve it(beyond tiny nitpicks).

This came about yesterday when I said Incredibles 2 was a great movie, but the Incredibles was perfect. It got me wondering if that was really true, and I honestly couldn’t think anything I’d change about it (beyond adding the pizza planet truck in the background).

What do you guys think? Can you think of any perfect movies? And do you have a different definition of what that means?

reply

To Kill a Mockingbird

A powerful story was translated onto the screen by means of a great screenplay, excellent direction, amazing performances by every actor, spot-on editing and a moving score.

Combine all that and you get a "perfect movie."

reply

[deleted]

For me, Psycho. That movie has been in my life for nearly 40 years and I never get tired of seeing it. Again and again, although I know the story inside out, I'm still mesmerised by the performances, the photography, the music.

Perfection incarnate (even though Gus Van Sant thought he could improve upon it!).

reply

...and surprisingly it wasn't bad. Heche can carry a movie all by herself.

reply

Erm, sorry can't agree with you there. I like Anne Heche but she was terrible in the remake, in fact everyone was. Same script, same shots, can't put my finger on it but it was all WRONG!!

reply

[deleted]

I still cant quite put my finger on why it doesnt work. The main thing for me was the screenplay just doesnt fit in the modern setting, plus the performances are all off and the actors miscast. Vince vaughn as norman WTF?!

reply

I got 4:::

"The Heiress" - 1949
"A Place in the Sun" - 1951
"The Asphalt Jungle" - 1950
"The Good Earth" - 1937

I can't quantify what makes them perfect. It was just an immediate response, a connection with each film at charter viewing. In my heart. In my gut. In my mind. There was never a doubt in my estimation that I was witnessing perfection. I see these titles on TCM and my heart races. I see them cited here and I'm a new man.

reply

Totally agree with "A Place in the Sun"

reply

I swear this topic appeared on reddit the other day.

reply

but rather a movie that perfectly accomplishes its goals

Exactly agreed, and I think Incredibles is definitely perfect. I often consider Fight Club to be in the perfection range as well, it's exactly what it wanted to be.

reply

Here we go:

https://old.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/8rzj4p/what_are_some_movies_you_consider_perfect_movies/

reply

Did you HAVE TO bring it over, Fred?

reply

I beseech your forgiveness. I'm just trying to figure out why someone would plagiarize a reddit thread.

reply

[Delete] it, I implore you, Fred. Please.

Obviously they wanted to share it with this site.

reply

I'll do it once we find out why the OP didn't even bother to write an original post. Putting one's own spin on an idea is fine, but copying and pasting a topic from another forum is just lazy.

reply

Wow that's strange.
The same user has now posted a topic identical to Stonekeepers weekly thread.
Think I'll give this poster a miss.

reply

The Shawshank Redemption. The story, the acting, the characters....it just worked perfectly for me. It's hard to explain.

reply

For some reason, this movie comes to mind because I can remember how it impacted me : https://moviechat.org/tt0087553/The-Killing-Fields

reply