MovieChat Forums > Politics > That all USA big cities are democrat, ho...

That all USA big cities are democrat, how is there still poverty in big cities?


How are wealthy people in big cities able to avoid having a large chunk of money taxed away from them to distribute to the people in the lower class of the big cites?

reply

1. Our government is a joke and is setup to sustain itself by..

2. Keeping it the rich sides game so they can enjoy life by keeping the minions fighting over stupid things that don't matter like...

3. Voting that doesn't work and only puts in office figure heads not related to those running things

reply

If you have never learned this by now, you aren't interested in learning.

But for a high level view
- Long time biases in home loans and banking practices and redlining led to there being pockets of poor minority people in cities. Other factors were cities systematically taking property away from Black people and seizing Black churches without fair compensation for urban development. Shifts to a car culture led to highways cutting through cities, and Black neighborhoods in particular were ripped apart by such projects.
- when racial integration was introduced, white people who could afford to move, left cities to go to suburbs where minorities were not allowed to buy houses. They took a lot of the tax base
- low income people are kept out of suburbs by purposely not having public transit.
- Forcing poor people (who as cited above were disproportionately Black) into certain neighborhoods created ghettos. Since poor people, regardless of race, commit more crimes, this led to a high degree of crime in these ghettos.
- Police did not protect people in ghettos but singled them out for aggressive arrest tactics. This enforces poverty in those neighborhoods because people who arrest records are banned from getting a lot of types of jobs. It also creates poor families with no father in the picture to help keep the kids growing up well.
- Republicans tend to hate poor and minorities so they elect republican leaders in their suburban enclaves. Democrats want to help those people so they are elected to run the cities, however their efforts are often blocked at the wider local level (e.g. my city of Pittsburgh is limited in what it can do without the buy-in of the county it is in) and state levels.

That is as succinct a story as I can tell.

reply

While you create this intricate, fictional backstory to explain away biolgical dysfunction, those of us in the real world understand that you can't polish a turd.

reply

Is that supposed to make sense? If it does in your mind, I guess you can't deal with any level of intelligent discourse.

reply

The problem with big cities in America is that they're mostly populated by inner city Americans. To pretend the problems stem from some convoluted web of historical injustices is ridiculous. Did you crib that directly from Howard Zinn?

It's. The. People. It's almost always the people.

reply

Brilliant. The inner city is populated by inner city people. What is your source for that bit of brilliance.

reply

The problem with Somalia is that it's populated by Somalians. The problem with Guatemala is that it's poulated by Guatemalans.

The problem with the inner city is that it's populated by...residents of the inner city. Capice?

reply

You are pretty ignorant of the history of these places.

reply

So the reason democrat city leaders are failing their cities is because republican suburban enclaves block city democrats efforts?

reply

In many cases. They also stuck away the tax base, as I said.

reply

Yeah, the second you see low income housing and public transportation show up it's only a couple of years before the place is a fucking shithole.

reply

Only the hardcore leftists still believe this bullshit salad of excuses.

reply

Righties have never refuted them because they are historical facts. You should study our country instead of your native Russia.

reply