MovieChat Forums > Politics > MAGA claims Roe v Wade decision a victor...

MAGA claims Roe v Wade decision a victory for "white life"


Miller: President Trump… I want to thank you for the historic victory for white life in the Supreme Court yesterday


https://twitter.com/Acyn/status/1540852015693037568

reply

What's wrong with white life? Do you want it destroyed or something?

reply

Lol, nice try.

It's weird that protecting white life is what she got out of the decision though. She knows exactly what her sheep want to hear.

reply

What do they want to hear?

reply

That Dumpy is saving White people from replacement.

reply

So you want white people to die? If they said it was a victory for “black life” would you be against that? Of course not because you and your cult are racist.

reply

Notice how they can't actually explain why its bad? The only response will be some reference to Hitler or some deranged shit.

reply

He didn't say it's bad, he said there's nothing wrong with this statement.

reply

No, the race bating trolls of this board.

reply

Notice how they can't actually explain why its bad?

I'll give it a shot . first lets examine the statement:
"Miller: President Trump… I want to thank you for the historic victory for white life in the Supreme Court yesterday"

Now lets transpose it to less context dependent phraseology:

"Thanks Donald, you banned abortion , this is good for white people"

On the face of it this seems to me that this Miller thinks having abortions is a bad practice , used mainly by white people and now it will be banned and lots of little white would-be-abortee babies will be born.

Why thats a victory beats me. It also doesent seem particularly insulting or racist to black people. More an admission theres lots of white people need to be told how to live their lives.

reply

See this is a sensible answer....but the OP is obviously implying a "muh white supremacy" narrative, based on their posting history alone.

They love to bait it, but tend to hide when challenged.

reply

I love how the resident trumptwats are defending the comment, meanwhile she's scrambling to walk it back!

https://www.mediaite.com/tv/congresswoman-who-thanked-trump-for-a-victory-for-white-life-at-maga-rally-hustles-out-frantic-walk-back-a-mix-up-of-words/

reply

It's a new world, or a return to the old one, with defending racist rhetoric.

reply

What a coward....she obviously meant to say it. Own your shit, lady!

reply

Somebody walking back a comment doesn't mean anything these days except that he fears the mob and doesn't want to get cancelled. Virtually nobody in the last 10 years apologized for a statement genuinely.

reply

Well maybe now in a few years they can reopen the swimming pools during the summer because now they have some lifeguards for them.

reply

She dog-whistled a little too loudly.

reply

No, it was a pretty blatant statement. Only leftys hear "dog whistles".

Again, why is her statement as stated, a bad thing?

reply

Because she admitted overturning Roe and Casey was to increase the population of white people, not save lives.

reply

Texas has a state out phone number to call if you know a lifeguard that isn't working. They can no longer have a summer off because there is to many ethnic kids that can't swim and will drown in rivers and lakes with the pools closed because of no lifeguards.

reply

Apparently she said this about Hitler a while back. Probably nothing related to this.

TEXT:

Rep. Mary Miller was speaking at a rally in Washington, D.C. when a Twitter user posted video Tuesday showing a portion of her speech.

"If we win a few elections, we’re still going to be losing unless we win the hearts and minds of our children. This is the battle," Miller is heard saying in the footage. "Hitler was right on one thing. He said, ‘Whoever has the youth has the future.

https://www.nbcchicago.com/news/local/chicago-politics/illinois-congresswoman-says-hitler-was-right-on-one-thing/2409325/

reply

Yup. She knows her crowd.

reply

Not wanting to be educated will only make you a democrat.

reply

I think anyone who says "white life" has potential racist views. Miller also said it to clearly push those views to those in attendance, because why bring it up at all when it's not absolutely necessary or needed to say it?

reply

I think anyone who says "white life" has potential racist views

Why?

Nothing racist what so ever to reference white life or white lives or for that matter white poeple in general.

Utter nonsense statement.

why bring it up at all when it's not absolutely necessary or needed to say it?

You mean like black people bringing up skin colour every day about nearly everything. How come that is fine but this isn't

reply

Well... to put it more precise... What could possibly be gained from mentioning "white" lives? It seems irrelevant to the situation.

reply

Why. What is wrong with saying white lives. It isn't racist in any way so why say it is

Would you say that if someone said black lives? No you wouldn't. So why is white lives racist.

Is the word white somehow racist in someway

It seems irrelevant to the situation

Your opinion. To them in may have relevant. Who are you to say otherwise.

This is why you can't have discourse anymore becuase the moment you mention white or white poeple it is slammed as racist and white supremacist. News flash it isn't

reply

"Why. What is wrong with saying white lives. It isn't racist in any way so why say it is"
Well , basically because it implies you dont give a shit about black people on the basis they are not white.


now we've answered that , can you answer the question about why you think she included it ? what do you think she meant by it ?

rather than answering with "Its not illegal!" or " its not racist" could you just say what you think she meant by it?

Pat has asked twice:
why bring it up at all when it's not absolutely necessary or needed to say it?
What could possibly be gained from mentioning "white" lives?


reply

Well , basically because it implies you dont give a shit about black people on the basis they are not white.

Mo it doesn't. Utter nonsense. You want it to be racist just because the word white is used. Just stop.

an you answer the question about why you think she included it

I don't care why she included it. I didn't ask or enquire about that and I don't reply to questions with questions which is what you are doing.

rather than answering with "Its not illegal!" or " its not racist" could you just say what you think she meant by it?

I don't care what she meant by it. You want me to say something so you can tehn call me racist. Saying white lives or white life is not racist. No matter how much you want it to be and lets be clear the point of your questions is because you believe it to be racist.

Pat has asked twice:
why bring it up at all when it's not absolutely necessary or needed to say it?
What could possibly be gained from mentioning "white" lives?

There are many things in conversations that get brought up that have no real relevance but are still used but that doesn't make them bad or in this case racist.

Like I said if someone had said black lives or black life you wouldn't have written a single word about it. Why is that. It is because you believe white people are the only ones who can be racist and the very mention of the word screams in your head racism. Pretty sad really. Little real world advice. ANyone can be racist of any colour, nationality, religion or race.

reply

as I predicted ,
You offer no insight into why she used the phrase
because the only possible reasons anyone could come up with would seem racist

I grant you "This is good for white people" is not a specific racist slur , but that is the ONLY possible subtext you can extract from it.
That, OR white people need abortion banning more than black people do - is that the case?

If she was talking about things that only apply to white people, like a higher factor sun tan cream or something then possibly the "good for white people" would be reasonable.





reply

Like I said if someone had said black lives or black life you wouldn't have written a single word about it.

You're one of these people who either cant or wont understand the phrase
"Black lives matter"
and going around saying "huh? racist! ALL lives matter" or worse "BLM = Rioting"

Completely oblivious to the fact that the true meaning to the phrase is
"Black lives are still suffering endemic racism at the hands of the police , the job market and other situations"

and hence needs to be pointed out
White lives dont need that

reply

All the righties are cult members here.

There's no chance of an honest discussion with any of them.

reply

And she won.
https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-endorsed-us-rep-mary-miller-wins-republican-primary-illinois-2022-06-29/
Miller is expected to win the district in November's general election.

reply

FAKE!!
But in reality, the Roe v. Wade decision was a victory for black life, since about 40% of all US abortions are black (despite black people making up just 15% of the US population).

reply