MovieChat Forums > mirelurk > Replies
mirelurk's Replies
Did he die of natural causes?
William Blake?
Statesman?
Explorer ?
Philosopher?
They cut him off
Non-binary people, who are the topic of this thread, don't all experience gender dysphoria. Your arguments are all surface level google expert stuff
If you wanna continue this convo start a new thread cause this one is getting weird
Trans women don't believe that they are real women. Or "cis" women. That's just you making assumptions that don't track with reality. Have you ever actually spoken with a trans woman and heard them say that they believe they have two X chromosomes?
No, not everyone who has sex is trying to have a kid. You are completely missing the point. I'm talking about why sex exists at all. Why it evolved and what survival function it possesses
This is my problem with anti trans people. They purport to be arguing on behalf of science but they're almost always total laymen when discussing science
Let me put it to you in the only way that matters: I don't decide what constitutes a mental illness. You don't decide. Committees of psychiatrists and psychologists gather every so often and deliberate on it
The current stance from the scientific establishment does not agree with you that trans people are all mentally ill
Not because they're being woke, it's because they have ethics that they follow and they need to be responsible about making glib assumptions
1. That would be the case if someone with XY chromosomes insisted that they actually had XX chromosomes. That would be a delusion by any definition. But no trans person makes those claims. You are labeling people as mentally ill without even trying to understand them
2. Yes but you can't tell whether a rocket is defective or if it's merely a design that you know very little about. You are labeling people as having a disease despite knowing very little of how doctors determine what constitutes a disease
3. Who says that sexual orientation has nothing to do with DNA? You're absolutely wrong about that. DNA might not be the sole determining factor behind sexual orientation but genetics absolutely plays a part
4. Nope, sex is absolutely only for procreation. More specifically it's a controlled method of adding genetic diversity to offspring. It only feels good for the same reason that eating food feels good, it gives your brain an impulse to do it
There is no argument for labeling trans people as mentally ill without doing the same for gays. Trans people do what makes them happy, same as a person following the "irrational" drive to seek sex
It's a generational thing. I don't expect you older people to ever understand the nuances of trans gender ideas, but you are wrong to simply write it off as a disease
Religion is a lot of very specific beliefs, some of which go against all accepted science
Why are some beliefs that "go against science" considered mental illnesses and some are just personal beliefs?
Also, no offense but I can tell that you are neither a psychiatrist nor a psychologist
What do you think qualifies you to decide who does or doesn't have a mental illness?
Do you know the process by which psychiatry decides what conditions to classify as illnesses?
And, again, why is homosexuality not also an illness? Sex is "objectively" a drive for procreation. Homosexuality cannot result in procreation. So why is that not also a mental ilness?
He seems like a spiritual person, I think he hates the phoniness of show business
Plus they are not accepting of his gerbil lifestyle
Is belief in God a mental illness in your opinion?
Beliefs are not illnesses, medicine only defines something as an illness if it is consistently harmful to your health
Beliefs or desires that are difficult for you to relate to or understand don't make them an illness
The way you feel about trans genders is exactly how your grand parents or great grand parents felt about homosexuals. It's not "natural", it doesn't lead to procreation, so it must be a disease
That's true
I thought Christian Bale was more of a simp Batman with Rachel. Or maybe a cuck?
Anyway, she is getting banged by Harvey Dent every night and Batman is still obsessed with her
I think even in your generation only a small minority of men would dangle job opportunities or free rent to women who weren't attracted to them
In other words, guys like you were sleazebags even in your own generation. There was just no internet for a wide consensus to form on how much your kind is despised
Don't listen to him, I'll miss you :(
She was great in Bully. But I think she's still married to Danny Masterson so she must be de facto blacklisted
Quid pro quo sexual harassment has been illegal for decades
Every post you make paints a portrait of a really gross and bitter old fart
You know what I mean. The majority of white land owning males