MovieChat Forums > gater > Replies
gater's Replies
Only confused by why anyone would defend this shit season
This 60 second video was better than all of S8
Shes the one characters that I would follow, as long as she used her faces.
It is true - if you knew these mothers you would know they had demons for years before they hurt their kids, others just didn't see it coming.
We had a close-up and personal view of Dany for years - her sudden transition into a executioner was total bullshit - completely unrealistic, awful, clueless writing - and only GOT fanboys like you would accept it.
That is epic - so much truth, and well done.
right - so disappointed in how it all turned out.
I think the real problem was that the writers were artists and not scientists - basic physics eluded them. That and plot armor.
Right - we see Jamie sinking deeper and deeper, wearing armor, pulling him downward and the next episode - magically he's laying on the shore. I was hoping he was dead - the show would have been more interesting without him.
I agree - they gave us a shit ending. They story became so illogical you couldn't enjoy it anymore - so much of it made no sense.
I thought the show started to go downhill at the start of Season 7 - Dany and the writers didn't seem to know what to do. And every bit of advice from Tyrion was wrong - I think he should be known as Tyrion the Traitor, he advises Dany to attack Casterly Rock instead of KL. He went along with the plan the bring a dead guy to Cersei - nearly everything he advised her to do was the opposite of what she should have done - he frees his brother, he cries over his sister - his true loyalties were exposed. He even convinced Jon to kill Dany which saved his own ass. So did Tyrion really think Dany needed to die? or was it that he knew how stupid Jon was, and could be easily manipulated.
lol right
Your right - I forgot about that - I was fully expecting the next episode to address his death - talk about plot armor.
2 Why would you think that Cersei would support the battle with the dead??? Apparently you haven't seen the 1st 6 seasons.
4 Why was Missandei on the ship, she couldn't ride a horse after the battle was over???
5 The chain of command was never made clear or else Jon and Greyworm wouldn't have had a conflict.
6 are you retarded? what makes you think the people of KL supported Cersei?
I agree - love the actors - hate the writers
Going from where Dany was, to the madness it takes to burn innocent women and children would takes years - like 20 to 30 years - it would be a slow process - but D&D had to do Star Wars - they couldn't be bothered with this show anymore.
Im only confused by why the writing became so bad - starting in season 7 there are multiple logical flaws in the story.
1 Dany lands in Dragonstone and doesn't attack KL? umm thats why she came to Westeros.
2 This retarded idea of bring a "dead guy" to Cersei? wtf??? Like Cersei was ever going to help - an idiot could see that Cersei was never going to help.
3 Saving the battle for KL for the end - The battle with the dead should have been saved for last - we learn about the dead in S1 Ep1 - "Winter is Coming" code for the Night King is coming. This was the biggest part of the story, save it til the end - we knew they would defeat the NK because the battle for KL is after that. - No real drama.
4 Missandei would never be on a warship - why was she there??? only so that she could be caught - horrible, clueless writing.
5 Who was in charge of the armies? Greyworm? Jon? Tyrion? there has to be a chain of command.
6 We see Dany for 8 years, freeing slaves, helping the oppressed - and all of the sudden she kills innocent women and children? no way - I call bullshit - This is like Arya suddenly killing Bran and Sansa - its not going to happen. Characters must stay true to their character.
The bolts from the Scorpions were heavy, they could reach a height of maybe 500 feet, and at that height they will have lost their momentum - Its clear the writers were artists and didn't understand the physics behind the Scorpions.
And according to the books Dragon skin is extremely tough, and nearly impossible to penetrate.
lol - they seemed to forget alot
it was so stupid - Dany knew about Scorpions - she could have flown high enough so that the arrows would never reach her - while she surveyed their fleet.
yeah, I never understood their seasons - was it like ours? or something completely different.