MovieChat Forums > Reacher (2022) Discussion > Would you accept a Black Reacher ?

Would you accept a Black Reacher ?


I feel its outdated casting white guys as heros.
We need to think new, fresh and out of the box. A black woman was cast as 007.
I would love a Black Reacher.
Alan Ritchson did a god job but white men are anti heros. I.e the bad guys were perfectly cast.

Any African Americans here agree ?

reply

[deleted]

I'm not african and not american, but I completely agree. A black woman as 007 would be great.

reply

Agreed. It should have happened a decade ago. I think that black chick who starred in Star Trek would have been a great choice.

reply

Eh,
I kind of like the characters to just stay as they are.
Here is the crux....why would it change?
Is there a reason to re-cast a fixed character and to alter them?
What is the point of trying to do that.

I wouldn't be up in arms about it but I don't really see the purpose in doing that.

They tried it with "Without Remorse" with B. Jordan playing the Tom Clancy character "John Clark".
I didn't like it but his race really had nothing to do with it.....they 100% changed the entire story to where it didn't resemble the novel in any way. I didn't think it was well written either.

If it were well written I'm sure I would have liked it.

But, bottom line....what is the point to making major changes to existing characters.

To make "Shaft" a white guy
To make "Reacher" a black guy....

Why?

reply

I've only read the first book in the series. Race is an issue in the book Killing Floor, but not the central issue.

I would have no problem with a non-white Reacher.

reply

Hell yeah! Fuck Whitey!

reply

Why hijack a franchise for your political ends? What is wrong with Shaft?

reply

How do you guys feel about a black Neagley? She is white in the books. She was not in Killing Floor though.

reply

Would you accept a white Shaft? A jewish Shaka Zulu? An eskimo portraying Michael Jordan? How about rewiting Donald Duck into a polarbear? Nice racebaiting, dingus.

reply