First the positives. Absolutely great production values. There's no denying done an excellent job of creating a show that looks, feels and sounds like Star Wars. That is with the exception of the very obvious animatronic Baby Yoda.
With that said I can't get over how repetitive the episode structure has been. If they wanted a show based on self contained episodic adventures, they should have done that and dropped the pretense of an overarching narrative that's building up to something. Almost every episode so far involves him meeting someone, gets easily convinced to help them with a very dangerous mission in exchange for information to get to the next fetch quest, only for the exact same thing to keep happening. I was really hopeful that the plot would really start to go somewhere with Ahsoka, only to be very disappointed with the episode ending with yet another "Sorry. Can't help you. Here's another fetch quest"
I don't agree with that at all. I'm not sure how you came to the conclusion that this is at all a common "Star Wars procedural" as you awkwardly put it, nor is that a good excuse for having such a repetitive plot structure.
They set him on this quest last season. If Mando comes to a final destination that'll be it, he hands Grogu over to whoever and is back on his own again. The alternative of course is that every attempt to find a better place for the child fails and he ends up adopting the kid permanently. But he's going to have to exhaust his options first. This season (and they're only eight episodes long) seems to be building toward Moff Gideon catching up to them, possibly capturing them. I'll bet that's going to be the cliffhanger ending. Either they're both captured or he gets Grogu and leaves Mando for dead - which of course he won't be. Could be wrong but that's my guess.
He's met potential allies this season, especially the last two episodes. I could see him next season agreeing to help Bo-Katan with her plans to retake Mandalore in exchange for her help rescuing Grogu from Gideon. I'm not minding the road trip/quest format of season 2. It seems like the logical continuation from where the first season finale left off.
The entire plot structure has literally been Mando gets lead,travels there, gets asked for help with a very dangerous mission in exchange for next lead. Mando easily agrees. Helps with mission. Gets another lead. Wash, rinse repeat. Very "video game-y" stuff & not a whole lot of meaningful story progression is my problem. Over half the season is over & the narrative has progressed very little which I would be more okay with if there was more variation in the structure of Mando's episodic adventures.
That's how you find something when you don't know where, or exactly what, you're looking for. You go from one lead to another. And Mando of course needs plenty of cash to keep his ship fueled and operational, obtain food and lodging, information, etc. Gotta pay the bills! Given his skill set, he's going to be helping people solve certain kinds of problems wherever he goes, so he can keep on going.
The Outer Rim is something like the Third World on Earth. People improvise with whatever's on hand instead of having the shiniest and newest hardware. It's a very commerce oriented environment where you trade something of value to get something of value. Help out of the kindness of someone's heart is rare. Even Bo-Katan, who was Mandalorian, had her own priorities and wanted Mando on her team for the assault. So she didn't tell him what he needed to know right away.
This is basically the classic story of a traveling gunfighter ... in space. Which is more or less what it's been advertised as. That sequence with the music and the murals at the end of each episode is straight out of an old school western. Maybe the problem is, you're expecting something more like the Star Wars movies in series form. The upcoming Obi Wan series will probably fit that bill.
Like what? I'm just not sure what you think they should be doing instead. Do you want more of the larger plot and less of the planet-of-the-week type stuff?
More plot would be nice but as I've said I'm fine with simple and episodic but would like each episode to have more varied sequences of events that take place than what we're getting.
For instance, maybe he shows up on a planet and has a run-in with a local crime boss. The episode is taken up by Mando running for his life and then returning to take out his adversary. He frees the locals from a bad situation. He walks away with a sack of the criminal's money. Maybe some information on a crystal, or chip, or whatever they use for data storage, that helps him choose his next stop. And they're off! Something like that?
Whatever it is they need to be mixing it up more than what they're doing. People seem to have a lot of overwhelming goodwill towards this show but that may wear thin if they just keep giving the audience the same thing week after week.
I'm sure the plotline of Moff Gideon and others trying to resurrect the Empire, and their interest in using Grogu's blood to transfer his Force wielding abilities to their own soldiers, has some significance to the overall SW story.
But otherwise yeah, this is just a long popcorn flick about a traveling gunslinger in a far off galaxy. If you go in with that expectation and aren't expecting anything philosophically deep it's a fun watch.
Its like watching all the cutscenes out of a Star Wars video game.
I still enjoy the show, it just feels pretty hollow. I'm not expecting any mind-blowing reveals, and that's fine.
Its well-made popcorn, imo. Delicious, but not very filling.
I've been mostly okay with the simplistic, not trying to do too much approach with this show. I feel they are mostly "playing it safe" the right way unlike the Di$ney trilogy which was a popular excuse early on to defend its significant problems. Still even with my critiques of this show I do think it's "okay" & very much agree about the ultimately hollow but well made popcorn fun that has at least thus far avoided stepping on the toes of established Star Wars lore. I don't mind simple but repetitiveness becomes tiring pretty quickly so I hope they change things up moving forward
reply share
agree. they shouldn't have releveled baby yoda right from the beginning. but they played it safe i guess. would have been cool to see full season of bounty hunting with baby yoda mission being season finale. right now it is very boring because we are more interested in finding out the main plot and not much on side quests.
I agree but I'm sorta OK with it. Lately the chefs in the Star Wars restaurant have been delivering rotten food. With this they have backed off and started serving the same plain hot dog instead. Maybe the same meal every time but at least it's a decent hot dog instead of terrible lasagna etc.
The repetition I'm chapped by is this: Mando talks to a fellow Mandolorian about their prophet/ancestor The Great Mandolore from the planet Mandolore who eats his Mandolore with his Mandolore.
My mother wants to start watching The Mandalorian with my dad starting with Season 1 because she really liked it when I had it on and already she has fallen in love with Baby Yoda and my mom told me she wants to watch Season 1 already so she can see the adventures. I especially love the scenes when The Child is eating soup and I keep telling my mom when I finally get my Baby Yoda plush that the next time I eat soup I want Mom to take our photo of us eating soup