MovieChat Forums > A Quiet Place (2018) Discussion > I wouldn't risk my life even 4 my kids.....

I wouldn't risk my life even 4 my kids....


Don't care, even if the wife says stuff about protecting a bunch of idiots from super extreme dangerous predators.

reply

You're gonna die anyway, very soon in the grand scheme of things. Doesn't matter if it's 10 minutes from now, or 50 years from now. If death is inevitable, your life has no value whatsoever. Also, if you die of old age, chances are, your death will be long, drawn out, and very painful... like it is for most old people. Might even experience the hell of alzheimers and dementia.

A quick, nearly painless death at the hands of a super-predator that kills you in 1 second flat... I could think of worse ways to die. As in, almost every other way to die.

reply

If thats your look on life, than having kids have no meaning either and saving them doesnt either.

reply

Bingo. Nothing has any meaning.

reply

You almost had me on the old age thing...
When my brother tells me that my good health means I'll outlive everyone and live to a very ripe old age.. I get depressed.
But you really aren't that nihilistic, are you? Nothing has any meaning?
I wouldn't even have to live to a ripe old age to be depressed if I felt that way. My whole life would be one big depression.

I can't imagine a more meaningful way to die than to save someone else...even if they were't my kids. Even if they were strangers.

reply

I don't really know. I go back and forth depending on my mood. The main point I was making, though, is that if life inevitably ends, then nothing really matters. Things, thoughts, emotions, deeds whether good or bad, only "matter" in that they affect people, are remembered, and felt. If your life ends, everybody else whose life you affected ends, then eventually, even the memory of things you've done also ends.

Now, if we have immortal souls or some such, then things have the potential to have meaning... potential. They still might not really matter. Even concerning this, physical death is still inevitable (as far as I know) whether existence continues or not... so physical life STILL isn't necessarily something to be cherished.

The other point I was making with my original post, is that if I'm going to die anyway, and it's inevitable, I might as well die for a "good" cause like saving somebody. It's because I'm somewhat nihilistic that I would willingly give my life for another person... not in spite of it. Strange huh? I also have a miserable life. I'd give you my last spot on the life raft because I kinda wanna die anyway.

reply

Why is your life miserable, if you don't mind my asking?

reply

[deleted]

I could say the exact opposite though, that your life has no value unless it has an inevitable end. Why should you value something that lasts forever?

reply

nice!

reply

You and the other guy both need hobbies.
If you think life has no value, you really gotta get out more.

reply

I feel sorry for you, if you wouldn't protect those that you claim to love. I know my parents would have walked through fire for me. Why? Because my dad did!

reply

COOL.

reply

Spoken like someone who doesn't have kids. I'd step between either of mine and anyone or anything that was trying to harm them; it's not something I'd actually have to think about, it would just ... happen. My wife too for that matter. I can't imagine my future with any one of them gone.

reply

Spoken like someone who does have kids. Its your evolutionary instincts and not logic speaking. You can always have more kids. You cant have a second life. Protecting kids is an instinct that has caused us a great deal of problems in the world.

reply