MovieChat Forums > Charmed (2018) Discussion > Why "woke" TV reboots don't work: "Diver...

Why "woke" TV reboots don't work: "Diversity isn’t a varnish you can apply to what’s familiar"


https://www.wired.com/story/tv-reboots-are-having-a-great-awokening-it-sucks/

Past TV shows rebooted to emphasize diversity, like Charmed or the upcoming Buffy the Vampire Slayer reboot are bound to be problematic, says Emma Grey Ellis. "This is where the of vast majority of woke-ified reboots fail," she says. "They respond to calls for change by retreading old ground—an insulting move on a few different levels. Reboots, remakes, and sequels abound because they’re easy to get greenlit: Executives feel safer shelling out cash for things they know have worked before, things that have a built-in audience. Which is already unsatisfying, but somewhat worse when you consider that many of these reboots have female showrunners and/or showrunners of color, some of whom have explicitly stated that doing a remake of an existing show is the only way to get their stories greenlit. The implication: Stories about women and minorities aren’t seen as marketable enough to stand on their own, unless they are standing on the shoulders of a story by and for white men. Which, even just from a box office numbers standpoint, is plainly wrong."

reply

Actually the only reason these women and minority showrunner can't get their own stories greenlit is that they aren't talented enough to come up with a good enough idea. So they just steal an existing idea and then try to slap a new coat of paint on it. Not unlike the idiots in college that would try to pass off an old term paper as their own by rewriting a couple of sentences though sadly Hollywood doesn't have the sense to tell these pathetic hacks to piss off.

reply

"But Doctor Who as helmed by Jodie Whittaker’s Doctor—whose band of friends (not companions, and certainly not assistants) comprises a Pakistani female police officer, a black warehouse worker with dyspraxia, and his white step-grandfather—finally looks and feels like the world I live in."

What planet is the writer from?😐

reply

amen my brutha

reply

I'm a sista...from another mista (I assume🤔)

reply

The problem with making everything political is that you are bound to lose a great number of your potential audience when you do it. Not to mention that even people who agree with the politics may want an escape from it every now and again and just watch a TV show.

reply

They really over did it. Plus three sisters that are all of a different race? What did their mother do have sex with three different PC approved men?

reply