MovieChat Forums > Uncut Gems (2019) Discussion > The Safdie Brothers hate their audience.

The Safdie Brothers hate their audience.


Inflammatory headline on purpose, but that's how I feel after watching two Safdie Brother feature films in a month.

They load up their films with unlikable characters, whose goals you don't support, give you scant reason to root for them (Connie in Good Time is one of the least sympathetic leads I've ever endured), and then kick you when you're down at the end.

You are pummeled with dread by these filmmakers relentlessly. In Uncut Gems, when KG shows up at the jewelry store and the doors won't open, I nearly walked out of the theater. How many times, and for how prolonged a period of time, can you assault your audience's sensibilities and expect them to stick around to the end?

Utter discomfort and denied resolution is how I describe movies by the Safdie Brothers, and I'll be avoiding the next one like the plague. Cheers to Adam Sandler for doing something different, appreciation for some great shots and cinematography, but my praise ends there.

Absolutely painful to watch.

reply

the door bit with KG get another meaning in the last act.

that's what called foreshadowing.

that is cinema my friend.

reply

Just cause it was foreshadowing of an event at the end, does not make countmaxwell's point any less relevant.

reply

but it does.
it has a reason.

reply

I agree, but it is a secondary reason. the extended length of the door issue was there more for the stress/frustration factor (countmaxwell's point) than it was to just set up a foreshadowing. Otherwise it could have been a quick, subtle plot point and then moved on.

reply

now you're just nitpicking/whining

reply

I’ve only seen two Safdie Brothers movies, Uncut Gems and Good Time. Both were excellent, tense stories about desperate, immoral weasels who feel the noise tightening try everything to slip away. Both Howard and Connie are selfish and self destructive fools who endanger everyone and everything around them and I found both movies very thrilling.

reply

It's a really weird and creative choose. But to think someone with that genius can make something so dull but genius, quite literally.

reply