By far the best, most effective scene in season 2 ...
– – was the one where the cartel’s lawyer, Helen Pierce (played by the great Janet McTeer) tries to persuade a night-cashier to hand over a hard drive with a key piece of surveillance footage on it. The kid keeps saying no to her. And comes to regret it.
The writing, the performances, and above all, the TENSION in that scene are just terrific. The sense of dread is almost palpable. It was as fine as any good scene in any good suspense film. (And it reminded me of the “coin scene” in No Country For Old Men)
And yet that scene could’ve been omitted from the show without having any effect on the main story (Helen could’ve simply told Marty that the cartel got its hands on surveillance footage; who cares how they procured it?)
And yes, granted, the scene does provide a good illustration of Helen’s character. We now see that she’s as cold and ruthless as a cobra. But my point is, the scene itself is narratively extraneous. You don’t NEED it to tell the story.
And yet that single, extraneous scene is the best one of the whole season.
Which, I’m sorry, does not speak well for the season.