MovieChat Forums > Star Trek Beyond (2016) Discussion > VOTE - Into Darkness or Beyond???

VOTE - Into Darkness or Beyond???


just type in the one you prefer. no reasons. just either Into Darkness (or STID) or Beyond (or STB) and we'll see which was the most popular (we'll leave out Trek 2009 as I think we can all agree its better than either STID or STB)

i'll start it off:

STID

reply

I like both a lot but I prefer Into Darkness.

reply

11-10
This is shaping up to be an eventually matched battle!

reply

Beyond

reply

[deleted]

Beyond

--------
My top 250: http://www.flickchart.com/Charts.aspx?user=SlackerInc&perpage=250

reply

Into Darkness

reply

13-11 to Beyond..

I have to say I thought Beyond would romp this but its actually quite even

reply

Into the Darkness by far.

I hated Beyond. Filmed too dark, dull generic action scenes, boring, too little character interaction, needed more focus on main characters - not boring bad guy and woman with crappy taste in music, generic plot, unoriginal storylines, whiny Kirk. This is now my least favorite Trek film.

reply

Into Darkness is so much better.

reply

13-13

Beyond struggling.. and on its own board too!

reply

The first 2 movies are way superior.

reply

I think that counts as a STID vote so for the first time ID is in the lead 14 to 13 

reply

Wrong. The first 2 movies are superior.

reply

[deleted]

That's just your opinion, I personally think Beyond is better than Into Darkness, although I do agree that the first movie is still superior, I think the first one is still the best.

reply

That's just your opinion, I personally think Beyond is better than Into Darkness, although I do agree that the first movie is still superior, I think the first one is still the best.


All of this is just our opinions.

But if we're weighing the movies on what a real Star Trek movie is supposed to be about, STID nails it, with its subplot on ethics, war crimes and eugenics.

The other two movies...?


"Can you keep a secret? Can you know something and never speak of it again?"

reply

Beyond is the better movie.

I'm a leaf on the wind. Watch as I'm needlessly impaled.

reply

back to evens then

reply

Beyond

reply

15-14 to Beyond

reply

Into Darkness is the best of the 3 so far, Beyond is the worst and most boring, it's just endless CG action with nothing but the most simple plot possible and no twists or anything interesting ever happening.

reply