1) The Empire Strike Back - A+
2) A New Hope - A+
3) Revenge of the Sith - A
4) Return of the Jedi - A-
5) Attack of the Clones - B
6) The Phantom Menace - B-
7) The Holiday Special - D
8) The Last Jedi - D-
9) Rogue One - D-
10) The Force Awakens - F
seconded. Ive cared more about the contents of the toiletpaper after wiping my arse than I do about what some butthurt poe fan boy thinks about star wars. Its kinda sad seeing someone so desperate to get a pat on the back from the other trolls.
I really loved ROTS, by far the most emotional and character driven of the Star Wars films. It lost points due to the over reliance on CGI and some of the corny love dialogue.
I agree the story was an absolute mess, the characters and the plot made absolutely no sense, but I'll be honest the acting was way better than Force Awakens (we didn't get any scenes such as "Did you see that") and at least John Williams was on his A-game here. That is the only reason I put it higher than Force Awakens and Rogue One, everything else about it was a complete disaster.
1) The original Trilogy
(Each one is a A+ to me)
2)The Force Awakens A-
3)The Last Jedi B
4)Revenge of the Sith B-
5)Attack of the Clones C+
6)The Phantom Menace C
7)Rogue One C-