It was terribly executed, it was god awful narrative wise as well. The soundtrack made my ears bleed and the characters actions made me want to tell at the screen. If this didn't have the Pixar name attached to it, it's score on IMDb would be much smaller. 3.5/10
I'm with you. This movie lacked the charm factor that most Pixar films are known for. The characters were bland. A waste for such a good cast.
There were times were I thought the script was going to really nail it... then it'd back off and just kind of use filler for lengthy periods. It's hard to have a kids' movie that has about an hour of absolutely nothing entertaining happening. (or at least it seemed like an hour)
I'd rank this as 2nd worst Pixar movie to date, only in front of Cars 2.
I think most people decided they loved this one before stepping into the theater. Because they hype is unwarranted and the trailer is 10x's better than the film itself.
I went with another adult and 2 kids (ages 10 and 13)... The unanimous response afterward was: Meh. And we never spoke of it again.
I was aware of the rave reviews, but it was still a film I had to be persuaded to watch.
I went in kind of hoping to dislike it because everyone seemed to love it.
It was great, although maybe more a film for adults as it dealt with the huge subject of a girl and her impending nervous breakdown.
From the ages of the kids you took, I can understand that Inside Out may have left them neither enjoying it as a piece of animation or as an intelligent piece of film-making.
I think it is. It's one of the few Pixar movies that I actively dislike. I know it's a kid's movie, but it's just so "white people problems" that it really bugs me. The whole concept of the "family breaking apart" and the child "rebelling" because they're moving to frigging California and the local pizza is no good... oh my, I wonder what that brat Riley would do if there were some real problems. The character design is meh. The people are well animated but the emotions... seriously, they just aren't cute. And the whole "inside the brain" setting felt unappealing and cheapish. The only thing I really loved about this movie is how they represented the process of growing up by mixing the emotions. That was really touching.
The whole concept of the "family breaking apart" and the child "rebelling" because they're moving to frigging California and the local pizza is no good... oh my, I wonder what that brat Riley would do if there were some real problems.
What is "real" problems? Are you allowed to be upset only in life or death matters or serious financial trouble? Are you only allowed to feel bad about life when you lost someone or got expelled from your house?
You realize that it's often because those kind of "little" problems are diminished, laughed at and not adressed properly that they get worse and lead to "real problems" later, right?
Because it's exactly what is depicted in the movie. A kid is facing a hard time and her issues are nearly not adressed properly and she could have gone on a bad path. Oh, sure, people move out all the time, that's not unusual. However, as a kid (and even as an adult), it can be pretty hard to adjust. You lose all your familiar surrounding, your friends, your hobbies, your identity... But that's no big deal, right, she has a house, her parents are not dead, so she really shouldn't complain, isn't it? After all, another kid has properly lost his parents in the meantime, or another is dying from hunger somewhere in Africa, right?
Do you really believe that she tried to run away because "the local pizza was no good"? Her family wasn't falling apart either, they were just adjusting to their life with little troubles (like the moving truck nowhere to be seen and the start-up of Riley's father that didn't go so well). Riley was not "rebelling", she was upset and didn't know how to deal with those kinds of emotions, because she never had to face them until then.
I really hate that mentality to just mock how people react to trouble in their life, without taking into account how they got there, what are their circunstances and why they did what they did. You're basically saying to them that their pain doesn't matter and that they should just suck it up and forget about it. Then they get ashamed, don't treat the cause, are closed in silence, and of course, things get worse later.
Everybody is different, everybody copes differently to different situation. The worst you can do is just to dismiss someone problems without adressing them because someone somewhere is worst off, or just judge people based on your own personal standard. It's not because you got over a break-up in one week that you should call dumb someone who needed two months or more.
The movie surely did go over your head.
reply share
I understand your point, but I disagree. Yes, I judge by "my" standards, but that's what 99% of population do and I fail to see the problem. After all, I'm only expressing an opinion about a movie, not about someone's real situation.
Also, "local pizza" was something called sarcasm, and there is a pretty big difference between just being "upset" and stealing your parents' money and running away, and 11 is not too young to understand that.
Yes, I judge by "my" standards, but that's what 99% of population do and I fail to see the problem.
Wrong, you judge without empathy, that is the problem (of many people). Of course it would be overwhelming to have empathy for everyone in the world at all time, but movies are places where your empathy is supposed to shine, where you can connect with the characters on screen because you follow their every action, thoughts and struggle, a place where you can root for any character, bad or good, as long as he/she is well written.
You didn't connect with her struggle, that's fine, but that's not the movie's fault, as it goes at great length to show you exactly the reason why she came to this.
Again, my main problem is the lack of empathy, to consider that your problems are more important than the problems of others. There are of course cases where some problems will be more pressing at adressing than another (you will first bring your child with a broken leg to the hospital before listening to your daughter who is going through a break-up, of course), but mocking people pain on a general basis is not ok in my book. You don't need to judge either, you understand or you don't, it's not up to us to judge anybody.
Remember the scene where Bing Bong is heartbroken because he lost his vehicle to the memory pit? Joy was trying to make light of his pain and didn't try to understand why he was upset in the first place, while Sadness listened and didn't judge, she empathised, and it allowed him to go past his pain.
You don't need to undestand or to agree, you need to listen most of the time.
there is a pretty big difference between just being "upset" and stealing your parents' money and running away, and 11 is not too young to understand that.
Age has nothing to do with anything, people do dumb things at all ages because a lack of maturity or self-reliance, or emotional turmoil. Riley was a sheltered kid who didn't have to face many difficulties until then, so it was overwhelming for her after having lived a life so much full of happiness until then.
Recently in my country, a teenager (around 16-17) pretended to have been kidnapped for a few hours and escaped by herself, just to cover the fact that she missed her curfew. Except it bit her in the ass when her parents took it very seriously and called the police, and they launched an investigation and everything, and she only admitted the truth a couple days later. Now she is going to get in big trouble with the law for false testimony and such.
Riley almost made a mistake, and returned to face her problems, which show growth and developping maturity in a very good way (unlike the teenager above, who let it go too far just because she didn't measure the impact of her lie and was too caught up in it).
Also, "local pizza" was something called sarcasm
I got the sarcasm (I got also the sarcasm in explaining the sarcasm), which is another proof of a lack of empathy by making light of Riley's pain also.
reply share
It's remarkable that I recently had a similar argument regarding this movie with my own mother. She didn't really like it, but she also defended Riley and blamed me for the lack of empathy, saying that what seems like a small problem to me may be huge for other people. Maybe you both are right, or maybe I just fail to make my point clear. but since explaining all my problems with this movie in full detail would probably require an essay in several pages and a far better command of English language, I'll just let it slide.
As a side note, though, it's a pleasure to read your responses, a level of conversation rarely seen on IMDb.
I had the same argument with her. But I would disagree - the whole Riley storyline is not central. So picking it apart seems excessive. But I took issue with the five emotions. They don't really act rationally. This movie was supposed to promote the "science" behind it all. But it was pretty silly, in fact. Overall, Riley seems like a good kid. And the only emotion I liked was Sadness.
I'm a Pixar fan, but this is probably the worst movie they ever made.
The straight forward story was boring, and most of the movie were in a depressive mood. Can't see why many kids would like a movie about depression, or a movie thats depressive most of the time. Looks like they ran out of story ideas after 15-30 minutes as most felt forced in to extend the runtime.
Well bscang90, it's like this. You probably aren't. I, for one, didn't think so. Here's why: a post of mine in Sept.
"Too much of a good thing is not always a good thing" I loved this movie. Yes, it's funny and a tearjerker. But understand, I grew up in a bubble created by my dad where there was no trouble or sadness in my childhood. Really! As a result, when I was on my own later I didn't know how to cope with sadness,adversity,confrontation, etc. I'm 67 and still passive. Real life has been hard to deal with. I've been a doormat all my life. So this movie was actually a simple education for me. I didn't pick it apart. I just watched it and was entertained and moved by it. And I could have used some Lewis Black in my life too!
You're not alone pal. I think the same. Insanely overrated turd, typical hypertrophy of substance over form. Could have been a masterpiece if hadn't been made with all this fillers put into just to make film longer, and these all tearjakers and just unbelieveably stupid plot devices which were to be metaphory for ,,inside out'' of our brain and emotions but turned out to be pathetic overall