Playtest is brilliant


What kind of stuff does one have to go through to come up with a story like that, I'd love to play that game though

reply

Ratings for Season 3:

Nosedive: 8/10
Playtest: 8/10
Shut Up and Dance: 9/10
San Junipero: 9/10
Men Against Fire: 7/10
Hated in the Nation: 9/10

reply

San Junipero: 9/10
How could you possibly give it a 9/10 rating? It was a cheesy romantic drama with a magical happy ending. Black Mirror is about the possible consequences of the direction society is headed. It's dark and scary. The point of that episode was basically "technology can give us eternal life with absolutely no negative consequences."

I think a 4/10 is generous. If it was a different show or a movie, then much higher. But it was like sticking a Seinfeld episode in Law and Order.

reply

san junipero's happy ending and overall positive note was not in line with the black mirror we know and yeah it was a little bit cheesy 😉 ; when watching it was more like an 8/10 but thinking about it afterwards makes more sense. The tech might even be possible in our lifetime with brain machine interfaces and research into it going on at several different unis incl. one i know at eth.

reply

San Junipero would have been great if it ended with the woman's husband and daughter waiting for her in heaven/some form of natural afterlife.

Grant discovered raptor eggs in Jurassic Park

reply

don't hold the show in a box. it can be whatever it wants to be. san junipero was really really good.

Voted biggest @sshole and role model of the year.

reply

Episode 2 is shocking indeed. But episode one has the best message of all.
I'd still prefer eps 1 to re-watch it over and over.

reply

[deleted]

I might be way off base here, I thought that the moral or theme has nothing to do with technology, it's that every action or inaction has a consequence. Had he answered the phone when his mother originally called, she would not have still been calling. Had he not stolen the information by taking a photo, his phone would not have been on, he would not have received the call which interfered with the device, he would not have died.

reply

You know, I've been a member of IMDB for like a decade plus, but I just felt I had to write a review for this one.

I bet Pokemons in Go! don't look that cute anymore :)

And the whole set-up is quite believable, after all it's established that Japanese do like twisted stuff in their culture (games, anime, hentai manga, TV shows which would make most Westerners blush with clear erotic objectives, and so on and so forth).

I like and respect them, but I could totally imagine a weird game designer from Tokyo designing something like this. Or worse, develop army interrogation applications.

I mean, it's quite Lovecraftian in concept and execution, 21st century be damned!

reply

Aside from the Season 2 Christmas episode, I'd say this is my favorite. I expected an ending like we got, since his mind was being screwed with, but I was definitely in my comfort zone of "it's over" when we got the real ending. . . if we really got an ending. *beep* for all we really know is his death was just part of the horror game.

Consider that the game (if there was a game) was designed to utilize his own brain to find his greatest fears and use them against him. Notice that his two major fears were 1. facing his mother (he thought she'd be behind the door) and 2. losing his mind like his father did. Then in the end he actually faces his mother, loses his mind, and "dies". Very possible he's still alive and we are the ones that never left the game.

reply

Slight spoiler, but did anyone else notice the Bioshock reference in playtest?

reply

playtest is the worst episode in the series. i don't know if you're trolling calling it "brilliant", but it is a really predictable and bad story. there are tons of movies that did the same thing and better. have you even watch some of them?

reply

It was in fact more or less the opposite of brilliant.

It was completely predictable, unoriginal and boring. You could seriously guess what happens if you read the description for the episode. Too many plot contrivances to ignore and the double Inception ending was terrible. I'm genuinely mad because I was actually expecting something interesting, seeing as it's Black Mirror. A disappointment, it's basically a C grade horror movie.

And people saying how disturbing and/or scary it was? Are you taking crazy pills?! The only somewhat disturbing thing is how many people thought the episode was good.

Lunatic with production values, that's the worst kind.

reply

It was completely predictable, unoriginal and boring.


You could very well be describing your own comment.

It's called an opinion seaward, and yours stinks.

reply

but the episode WAS predictable and unoriginal. there is no way to deny that. it's not an opinion matter, it's a fact. that's the same plot a dozen movies already did in a better way. i wouldn't say boring because i am always hoping for the best when i'm watching a black mirror episode, but this one was pure *beep*

reply

Predictable in the sense that they followed a logical conclusion, maybe. Unoriginal though... come on. I hate this kind of critique because it is itself bland and unoriginal and adds nothing to conversation.

The actual structure may have been predictable to some degree, most things are. It's the beats within it that define it as a story though and I don't agree that it was this wholly predictable, borefest you assert it to be.

If you really want to play the originality card game though. Why don't you name a few tv shows, or perhaps films would be better since this show is an anthology series, that are shining beacons of unpredictibility and we'' see what we can compare them to.

I don't want to hate people, but people make me hate people

reply

Calling something out on being unoriginal is now unoriginal? Come on.

Yes, unoriginality doesn't automatically condemn the idea as long as they put a new spin on it. As Black Mirror is usually known to do. This time they just failed.

Lunatic with production values, that's the worst kind.

reply

https://media.giphy.com/media/3oEduO4hD4KjTLlj2g/giphy.gif

Lunatic with production values, that's the worst kind.

reply