For those who haven't seen BR


DONT! For the love of all that is holy, don't! It's a shît movie. I kept hearing the same bs about HG ripping off this masterpiece called Battle Royale. So when I saw it on netflix, I figured I'd give it a shot. Such a horrendous POS! HG is far superior to BR. Not in originality cause technically BR came out first. But considering the only thing similar is the basic plot line being teens pitted up against each other in a fight to the death, HG isn't a ripoff. It's a completely different look, take, morals behind the games, morals addressed in the movie. Etc. still jus because everyone in HG is a better actor than anyone from BR isn't it's only problem. It's jus awful, I advise nobody waste their time giving these BR trolls the benefit of the doubt cause I was *beep* Also the whole movie is in Japanese or Chinese or some bs so you'd have to read this terrible story on top of everythin else.

reply

After all the "hoopla" on these movies, I watched BR on Netflix..snore...sorry folks, but I will take the Hunger Games series anytime..

reply

The plot of Battle Royale 2 which came out in 2003.

"It's a story of adolescent boys and girls being randomly pulled into a filmed game show of a gory deathmatch in an arena filled with natural and artificial hazards set in a dystopian society with a totalitarian government that likes to show the people that they're still in charge. Some of the contestants embrace the opportunity to cause mayhem; others try to navigate the situation with diplomacy, only to be ruthlessly murdered by more vicious players. The story ultimately focuses on a trio of protagonists, one slightly older and embittered by loss because he has played and won the game before; the other two are younger and more innocent, and turn to their more mature peer for guidance and inspiration. In the end, instead of the usual one winner, there is a plot twist and the two younger players become lovers and end up winning the game in the end. Then they go on in the next story to try and overthrow the totalitarian government."

What gets me the most is that Suzanne Collins said she's never heard of BR. I can only guess why though, the reason being she would probably get sued.

reply

big-budget Battle Royale remake film had all the chances of becoming a spectacular film that would be faithful to the original books written by Kousen Takami. Instead, what we get is mostly just the first third of the book expanded into an emoes-at-hogwarts film that is not entirely bad in its presentation inna TV-movie sort of way, but not what I would go to see this in the theaters for. The last tow thirds of Battle Royale's elements and characters are entirely left out, possibly for a sequel film but who knows, leaving us with a dumbed-down adaptation designed mostly to get people in the theater seats to watch it. The 2000 Toei version was much better at handling the entire story, compressed as it was for the amount of screen time the studio could afford to show it in.

reply

I agreed with you on the apples nd oranges as I didn't think these films were hardly related besides base idea. But I don't agree that sayin HG is better than BR is like comparing the other movies as twilight was awful and Godfather is a highly known awesome trilogy while BR isn't even nearly as recognized. Furthermore, I jus didn't find BR to be anything but boring and bad acting and too much stupid subplots that were some unrealistic. But I guess if y'all liked it that's your opinion. I was jus sayin that I wouldn't recommend it to anybody who hasn't seen it.

reply

At this point, teen dystopia is an established genre, but at the time the book was published (Sept 1999) it was the first of its kind. This is during the halcyon days of the Bush presidency and right at the start of the economic crisis and the 9/11 collapse. There was a tremendous climate of uncertainty and fear, and Battle Royale offered a counterpoint with a world that was even more *beep* up, and it resonated immediately with a young audience. It's easy to dismiss it now because of the Team Shuya/Kitiyama *beep* and screaming tweens, but some of the social themes that Battle Royale addresses (devaluation of life, government corruption, disposable pop culture, etc) speak directly to this generation.

reply

Very good comparison work, and i had already told my kids about THE OMEGA MAN as well. The power of Battle Royale II, however, lies precisely in it's being in this world - way more scary an exposition of what humanity is capable of. HG's underclass reminded me, with Christian Bale, inevitably, of Equilibrium. I think that as a study BR2 has a unique tension. The wider parable of post-Armageddon societies+media makes HG a broader beast but in retelling that by now old tale it loses the concentrated impact of BR2. Whether it is greater by trying to do three things (psychology, brave new world, gladiatorial arena) instead of one, is thus seriously open to question.

reply

I had my wife watch BR after teasing her about how similar they were. I like them both. BR is a condensed version and she liked it but THG is fully fleshed out due to the books and long movies. Depends on my mood which one I watch.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]