MovieChat Forums > The Revenant (2016) Discussion > Why didnt the Bear kill Leo?

Why didnt the Bear kill Leo?


I assume it wasnt hungry, but simply wanted to protect her cubs. But why didnt she finish the job?

reply

Animals might be violent in their defence of their family but they're rarely vindictive. Once Leo seemed to be incapacitated she would almost leave him alone, until he stirred her attention once more.

I suspect that in a real fight with a bear it would simply come down who killed who in the first conflict, no buggering about, but then I have 0 experience with bears. And I don't really want any either.

reply

so in animal rationale if that is true humans should kill bears and other aggressive animals at first sight? since they would do the same.
done.

reply

Nope. Animals kill out of instinct with the intention being to eliminate a threat or to eat. Humans, for the most part, have beaten natural selection and evolution and thus have other complex motives to kill (sport, satisfaction, sadism, business etc.). Furthermore, animals rarely kill or attack on first sight simply for the sake of it. Almost all predators all the way up to bears prefer to run away upon confrontation unless they are hungry, threatened or have offspring to protect.

I feel like you didn't really comprehend what the comment you responded to was trying to say at all.

reply

therefore humans should kill out of instinct since as you define it, it comes naturally. if i see a bear or other animal that isnt a prey animal, i shall attack it at first sight, since they would instinctually do the same.

you assume humans cannot use their natural instincts anymore. that is bullcrap.

reply

A natural instinct for a human when seeing a bear is to get away from it.

How are you going to kill it? With a gun? Then that isnt natural is it.

If you attack a bear on first sight with your natural weapons, you will die.



"Men on fire pray for rain"

reply

i can kill a bear with the weapons and tools i craft as a relative to apes, therefore if i have a knife or sword, or gun, it is a tool used to kill. what isnt natural about using tools? idiot.

hell if i light a bear on fire with a rag and alcohol, how is that not using tools like our primitive ancestors? oh thats right its the same thing and you are an idiot.

reply

what isnt natural about using tools? idiot.


Moron quote of the day.

Look up the word natural and come back to me. Being part of nature is not having a machined man made gun and ammo, you blithering idiot.

A humans natural instinct when faced with a bear is not to attack it. Moron. Its to stay well away and avoid the danger.

I would like you to try lighting a bear on fire and while the huge flaming bear rips you to shreds, in your final moments you may realise what a wanker you are.



"Men on fire pray for rain"

reply

PEOPLE !!!

Too many of you believe falsehoods about bears!!!

In my county in NJ a bear ate a man in September, 2014!

Bears attack humans regularly and eat them as well!

"Bears don't want to eat you." Many do!

"If you play dead you are safe" No!

Please don't go hiking in bear country with these false beliefs.

Have a look at this list which dispels many of the "truths" people are spouting here:

http://www.bearsmart.com/about-bears/dispelling-myths/

reply

so then an ape using a stick to reach something it cannot get without using tools is not considered natural by your definition?
idiot.
guns are tools, that humans use like sticks, to solve a problem they cannot solve using just their bodies. therefore swords, knives, guns, missiles are all improvised tools that humans create.

so yeah, you are the moron of the day. LoL! you owned yourself with your idiocy.

reply

Do us all a favor and go fight a bear.

reply

There is a difference between using a stick to collect termites and using relatively more complex machine with moving parts, gunbowder, etc.to kill a bear.

If you're happy and you know it, go sit in the corner and think about your life.

reply

Glass probably should've just slowly crawled away from the bear.

reply

Bears rarely kill humans; humans regularly kill bears.

Same for most other species known as brutal (sharks, wolves, et cetera).

reply

You just answered your own question.

I don't think bears usually kill and eat people unless they are really, really hungry.

Check out this upbeat documentary called Grizzly Man.

reply

When I'm in Northern Ontario there is an iron clad law that I adhere to - for the sake of my life.

Never get between a Mama bear and her cubs.

reply

Having done my fair share of hunting, I enjoy game meat on my dinner table, you don't go into the forest without binoculars. Bears are usually laid back beast, unless fed, they usually avoid humans. However if you're in the woods in late October there is a tangible that you have to be aware of. If a bear hasn't stored enough fat for its hibernation it will look upon you as food. If a hungry bear charges you have only one shot before it tears you a new Arsenal. You have to shoot it through the heart, anything else and the bear is on top of your. And it goes for the richest store of protein - your brain.

As a hunter I've always eaten what I've killed, those that hunt for sport are degenerate cowards.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uRiVkmiSiIU

reply

I always wondered why bears seem to go right to the face when they attack people. I always thought it was just to "disarm" the human.

reply

I always wondered why bears seem to go right to the face when they attack people. I always thought it was just to "disarm" the human.



the face is like a threat of some sort.,if i remember, BC of our teeth. gosh i wish i could remember distinctly why, but i do remember the facial/head area is usually first to get attacked. these animals are intelligent., problem solvers.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
"I have never seen a vision, nor learned a secret, that would damn or save my soul"!

reply

As a hunter I've always eaten what I've killed, those that hunt for sport are degenerate cowards.


And thoes that hunt does'nt have a local store? Oh yeah they do. So truth be told you kill things for sport as well. Not judging, just saying.

---------------------------------
* My God!.. Its Full of Stars! *

reply

What he does is that he helps the environment by keeping the wild animals poppulation controlled, and he gets way better meat than you and i get at the "store".

reply

Thanks for the replies guys - I know nothing about Bears. I only assumed Hugh Glass would go the same way as Timothy Treadwell.

reply

I thought it was funny the way she stood on his head with her claws out.




Spotlight: 10
Brooklyn: 9
Room: 9.5

reply

Since in this case she was primarily defending her cubs and thought Glass was no longer a threat, she desisted. Chances are when she came back a second time she might have left him alone. Unfortunately Glass panicked, was once again perceived as a threat and was savagely attacked again this is all of course, pure congecture. Fact is animals can act in any number of different ways and are as unpredictable as humans.

reply

Chances are when she came back a second time she might have left him alone.


Actually -- she had walked away after the first time she mauled him, because I guess she figured she had "won," kicked his ass, and thought he was probably dead.

When she stood on his head with her claws out, making a kind of "whuffling" sound and looking around not at him but at the trees, she seemed "satisfied."

If he had just bitten the bullet after the first mauling, played dead and lain completely still and let her go without shooting her, he might have avoided the horrible second mauling.

He would still have been messed up, but not like he ended up being...





Spotlight: 10
Brooklyn: 9
Room: 9.5

reply

That's what I heard, that if you 'play dead' after the initial attack the bear will often lose interest and leave.

When I was in Yellowstone I went hiking with a friend who had just done a ski season in the Rockies in Canada, and he says 'we have to buy bear spray'. Er, what now? So we go into a gas station, get our big old can of bear spray, and I'm reading the instructions in the car enroute. The below is from wikipedia, but you get the gist:

Bear spray is intended to be used to deter an aggressive or charging bear. A user points the canister at an aggressive bear and sprays the contents for at least 6 seconds. The recommended minimum distance between the user and bear is 25 feet (7.6 m). Using the spray improperly can have undesirable effects. Because the deterrent effect depends on the bear receiving a concentrated dose of spray, using bear spray on objects or clothing is not effective, and can actually attract bears.

I don't think I'd have the guts to wait for a bear to get within 7m of me before pepper spraying it!

In the movie, I assumed Leo's character would have knowledge of bear behaviour, it actually surprised me that he provoked it a second time.

It's too cerebral! We're trying to make a movie here, not a film!

reply

In the movie, I assumed Leo's character would have knowledge of bear behaviour, it actually surprised me that he provoked it a second time.


Yeah that part was a bit silly. Why on earth would he do that and provoke the bear again?

Poorly Lived and Poorly Died, Poorly Buried and No One Cried

reply

Uh, what? Look at the scene again. That bear is not going anywhere. She is still only a few feet away watching over her cubs. He could have bled to death waiting for her to move on, so it only made sense that he would try to shoot her.



"A little Consideration, a little Thought for Others, makes all the difference." Eeyore

reply

The bear was coming back to him I think.

reply

Yes! the bear was definitely coming back up to him when he shot it. Not to mention... being in that situation you would probably panic anyways.

reply

Exactly. He had to be proactive in order to get out of there and get some medical attention.

~~~~~~~
Please put some dashes above your sig line so I won't think it's part of your dumb post.

reply

You never know with bear attacks. They will often return for a second or third mauling, even if you play dead. May also take a bite of you.

He chose to shoot the bear because it was likely coming back, and a shot bear is more likely to leave and not come back.

To me it looked like the bear was checking on her cubs, before coming back to investigate Glass again.

reply

Because he shot it and then stabbed it.

reply

Watch Backcountry for a better bear attack.

reply

Bears aren't the smartest animals. If you play dead, which I think is what Glass did, you could survive a bear attack. The bear just wants the threat eliminated, they don't really want to eat you. I've seen a few articles that said people have survived doing this.

reply

If you play dead, which I think is what Glass did


Yes, you are correct, he was lying perfectly still for that exact reason.

However, it's still no guarantee that the bear will leave, I think that's why he shot it, it was still moving towards him.

reply