Where is Judith?


Did I miss something? I don't remember her dying, but she seems to have disappeared as if she never existed.

reply

Really? Of all the possible gripes to have with this show, I can't imagining (until now) anyone complaining that we're not seeing enough Judith.

She--her character, a baby--shouldn't exist anyway. She doesn't exist at all in the comics, for good reason. A group of post-apocalyptic characters wandering around in a dangerous landscape with an infant doesn't generate much credibility, if any.

reply

Sandoz, please quote me where I stated that "we're not seeing enough of Judith". Look at the three words in the title of my post. Which part of "Where is Judith" do you not understand?

reply

Well then, to strictly answer your question...

Judith is not on screen. No-one cares where she is. It's a good thing.

reply

I'm so impressed with your insight ("not on screen") and mindreading skills ("No-one cares"). What did the film critics ever do without you!

reply

Thanks. Please get back to us and share your joy with us whenever Judith reappears on the show.

reply

No need to share anything with you, since you already know what everyone is thinking.

reply

Not really. I thought you were clueless, but now I realize you're just tasteless. My mistake.

reply

Someone who can't understand a three-word sentence thinks I'm is "tasteless." LMAO!

reply

She is at Hilltop

reply

So agree - babies would never make it in the ZA.

reply

Judith was shown a few times this season.

Negen even got to hold her when he brought Carl back to Alexandria.

reply

who cares? She's just a plot point. I can't stand kids in the ZA. Waste

reply

LOL! Get out of my head! Hahaha . . . your response is literally what I thought of when I saw the question. I'm just happy Judith is away and not causing anyone any problems.

reply

WORD UP!!

reply

With Maggie at Hilltop

reply

She's around. I'm curious . . . do people really care about Judith? LOL! I honestly don't care about her at all. I heard she died in the comics . . . . . I'm just saying . . .

reply

Yep, she died during the Governor's attack at the prison. Definitely a +1 for the comics over the TV show.

reply

LOL!! Agreed!

reply

I'm glad she's alive because she represents hope in that miserable world. But I'm more glad that we barely have to see her and can just assume she's off cooing somewhere in the background. ... being non-disruptive and pissing off as few people as possible by her very existence.
I don't have to see people going to the bathroom to know it's in between the scenes that we see.

reply

It annoys me when writers give a character a baby then forget it exists. For one, it makes the character a shitty parent. Two, babies take up loads of your time, energy, and emotion. If you want the character to have a baby then the baby should constantly be part of the story.

reply

" If you want the character to have a baby then the baby should constantly be part of the story."

Why?

reply

Not much of a reader are you.

reply

Why can't we assume things take place that we don't see? Why must we see everything?

How much bitchery do you think we'd see if they showed too much Judith when people are already complaining about the fact that she even exists when they don't have to see her all the time..

Judith may have a place in the show when she can do more than coo and piss and sleep.

reply

I actually agree with you, and I fucking hated babies before I had a couple. Actually, I still strongly dislike other people's children, but I love my own. It's super unrealistic for Rick to be doing any of this shit when he has a baby, because if someone like myself couldn't imagine doing anything other than taking my kid and getting as far away from any dangerous situation as possible, then pretty much anyone who's not straight evil would do the same. So basically it just makes Rick seem disgustingly shitty.

reply

Same, didn't like other people's kids and still don't but unless you are a horrible person, kids are part of your everyday life, a consideration in every decision. I would no more pawn my kids off on others than I would ask strangers to keep my wallet.

reply