MovieChat Forums > Rebel Moon - Part One: A Child of Fire (2023) Discussion > Did anyone actually expect this to be go...

Did anyone actually expect this to be good?


Snyder movies always suck

reply

Not true, 300, Watchmen and Dawn of the Dead are good films, and I would go so far as to say Watchmen is borderline, one of the greatest superhero movies ever made.
And his extended Superman and Justice League cuts were rather decent.
So yeah, I had high hopes for Rebel Moon, and was hoping it would be a return to form for Snyder, but alas, what we got was an unoriginal, poorly written steaming pile of woke shite.

reply

Yep, those are the three I always list as the good Snyder movies. What the heck happened to the guy?

reply

I have no idea, but he’s on a similar trajectory as the Wachowskis, started out utterly brilliant and quite possibly subverting the paradigm with his and their visual style, and then somewhere along the line wtf happened.

reply

Yep. Every single time.

I'm surprised some people still hype him and expect good things. Every his movie after Watchmen sucked. 300 and Danw of the dead were other good movies of his. Everything else is bad.

reply

I expected it to filter everyone as usual, but this movie just flat out sucked.

reply

it was great

reply

No, and I heard about this movie long before it came out. It sounded like another woke Star Wars ripoff, and I had no desire to watch another lame, poorly-written girl-boss beating up space Nazis with her diverse gay friends teaming up to destroy the cliched evil empire. That story's been done to death ever since the first Star Wars film in '77. It got kinda old 20 years ago.

reply

No, but that's due to the trailer.
Snyder does well if he's not writing the script.

reply