Vote NO to Organ Donation

I respect your view, however, the difference between the movie and real life is that organ donors are not alive in the same sense when their organs are acquired. One can argue that people don't stop living after they die - depending on what you believe - but to me, it would be pointless to keep my organs if I don't need them anymore, especially if they could save someone else's life as opposed to just rot in the ground.


I only do it with superheroes.

One day I will very likely need an organ transplant to live...so I can`t agree with you.

"That movie gave me drunk-in-the-bathtub face!"

Read what happens to a body when it's embalmed.

When I'm dead, if somebody can use my organs they are welcome to them.

Watch a good movie about organ donation like "Return to Me."


If you're too old to cut the mustard, you can always lick the jar.

Corpses don't need organs. Living people do. I don't think 'selfish' is a strong enough word to describe people like you.

---

heh Using this movie as a basis of support for the idea that people should not be organ donors is like using Alien to support the idea that people should not go into space.

I smell a troll but it's a funny one.







The Survivor Funny 115:http://funny115.com/

I shouldn't worry If I was you love as it is illegal to clone humans in the states ( remember when that was science fiction ? ) and as it happens they are working on cloning just the bits n bobs you need ( look up mouse grows human ear ) Though I do agree with you as to if it came down to using a full clone as the people in the movie seemed Very human I could not understand how any rational thinking person would allow that, I mean if I was there I would like to think I would have been part of an underground to help send them to a place they could live. But that may just be the rebel in me =}

While I can't imagine anything more cruel, inhumane or heartless than growing genetically "perfect" humans just so they can be "organ donors" (as in this movie, and at least one other I've seen), I have the Organ Donor "thingie" checked on my Driver's License, since I see it as equally senseless to let perfectly good organs go to waste once someone's body (including mine) is no longer functional.

The statistics are that literally tens of thousands of people -- many children, teens and young adults -- DIE each year in America, alone, because they can't get a kidney or a lung that WOULD be available if most people were organ donors. THAT is the true travesty. Yes, science IS on the verge of being able to grow organs in laboratories. Once such science is perfected, the need for organ donations may diminish or even be totally eliminated. But until that day comes, I can see no sane reason not to agree to donate your organs once your physical body is gone.

Note that we all call it "our body," "my body," etc. We don't call it "me," "I." Most of us seem to be at some level of agreement that whatever makes up the "me" or "I" leaves the physical body when it ceases to function... the soul, per se. So if most of us agree on that, then why should we deny the leftover organs for someone else??? As for those who proclaim to be Atheists, they believe there's nothing after, anyway, so they would have no further use for the body, either.

At any rate, this was ONE haunting movie, possibly the highest rating I'll ever give a movie that left me so depressed.
Jeff Hayes

Jesus Christ.
Too many f--king idiots on this board.