Clyde Shelton - villain, hero or anti-hero?
In some ways a hero, and not really an outright villain but overall I would say anti-hero. Agree?
shareIn some ways a hero, and not really an outright villain but overall I would say anti-hero. Agree?
shareI consider him mostly a villain. While his intentions seemed good, he started killing innocent people like his cellmate and Sarah who had zero to do with his tragic misfortune, and he killed everyone but the one man who he should have killed. He's a sociopath who felt he was justified in harming others and making Nick suffer because he didn't get the outcome he desired.
shareDefinitely a villain. He may have believed he was doing the right thing, but his methodology was totally psychotic.
shareSomewhere in the middle, the night his family were murdered was what really broke him, and was hellbent on getting justice for their deaths, but he did not trust the flawed justice system and took matters into his own hands
shareI go for anti-hero.
shareAnti-Hero, though I rooted for him the entire film. He was clearly broken from his wife and daughter's deaths.
sharesomewhere in between - he took out a lot of right people, but also there were also plenty of 'collateral damage', as our dear leaders would say
shareThe thing is though, since it wasn't war and it looked like it was done intentionally and he held a grudge against those who may not have been evil themselves but in his view deserved to die, it was more than just "collateral damage" and I believe that this term isn't exclusive to what American leaders would say and for one in any war, even "just war", it happens all the time.
But the scenario portrayed in this movie was different to that of a war. And because he alone was responsible and targeted individuals personally (weren't all his kills intentional?), all questions especially degree of labels and guilt (in this case, villain or NOT) apply to him.
And I am guessing in between really would mean anti-hero (like for instance, Travis Bickle was in "Taxi Driver" (1976) to name a classic example.)
when I use the term 'our dear leaders' - I am referring to all dear leaders - after covid, I am convinced that they are all part of the same cabal. It's all a theater at this point - the world's a stage.
As for the film - he had a greater goal in mind - all people that had to be taken out in order to achieve that goal were either guilty or collateral damage in his view.
And yes - ultimately, he is anti-hero, in my opinion. The film producers/director obviously saw things differently, given the ending and the focus on the corrupt fellow smiling - but it wasn't an evil smile - he was in the director's view the true anti-hero character.