MovieChat Forums > Dune: Part One (2021) Discussion > Do I need to have an understanding of th...

Do I need to have an understanding of the game Dune to see this?


I want to see it on Tuesday but wonder if I should do some research. Will it help me get into it to know something? Or just go in fresh?

Thank you.

reply

I don't know a thing about the game. However, this is based on the book, Dune, by Frank Herbert. You can probably enjoy it without having read the book, but I would recommend you read it when you can.

Unless you are a very fast reader, I would doubt you can complete the book before Tuesday. Read the book after you see the film and it will fill in a lot of the holes a movie adaptation must suffer to be filmable.

reply

I have no previous knowledge, no idea if it was a game or a book first, and also didn't understand much of the story - much like a history movie. I have no idea who is who but the visuals were nice.

reply

I saw it and agree. Seemed to be three different groups, the main family, the sand dune people and the emperor. I couldn't really get my head around the plot. I just knew that the Emperor wanted them dead.

reply

I have played the games, but I didn't read the book, didn't watch the first movie either, just this one.

I realized that Fremen should've been a faction in the game, at the same time I have no clue where the Ordos fit in the story (maybe in part 2 we'll see them?).

reply

3/10.

Nice angle but you should’ve elaborated on the game.

reply

An understanding of Islam would be better. This is parable of how Islam came about, and Paul is Mohammad.

..Joe

reply

This is a weird thread for the generation who read the books. It was so famous that even people who didn't read sci-fi read it. It was one of the few sci-fi books (along with later Heinlein books) you'd pickup at the airport as a holiday read.

reply

Where it was so famous? Perhaps it was widely known in the US, and not so much in other countries. The games were known worldwide. Something like the Marvel comic books being well known in the US, but completely ignored in the rest of the world, while the movies are a global phenomenon.

reply

I live in the UK but this may be more of a when rather than a where question. I read it in the 70s/80s and many people I knew did. The original film was also quite a big thing - even though much criticized at the time - I liked it and so did people who didn't normally watch sci-fi.
Interestingly I don't remember people complaining they didn't understand the first film when it appeared as they seem to be doing now - not sure how you interpret that.

reply