MovieChat Forums > Scream (2022) Discussion > Scream 4 vs Scream 5

Scream 4 vs Scream 5

posted 3 years ago by DAVID62627 (441)
18 replies | jump to latest

Which is better?

[–] ridah (291) 3 years ago

Scream 5 was worlds better. #4 was terrible, #5 was superb.

[–] Nina (545) 3 years ago

I wish they would have stopped this movie by scream 4. Cause this one was really great and couldn't be topped!
Scream 5 was garbage!

[–] Jones70 (6872) 3 years ago

Scream 5 is way better.

[–] mirelurk (884) 3 years ago

4 has WAY better writing and directing, but its cinematography is seriously fugly as shit. It makes it almost hard to watch

5 had good moments but, overall, it was pretty meh

I just got done bingewatching the entire series in one day, so both are perfectly fresh in my memory

[–] Tongue (496) 2 years ago

Scream 1 was truly magical -

Scream 2 was a pretty solid sequel m

Scream 3 was just ok - it still had sone charm

Scream 4 and 5 aren’t terrible but not very rewatchable

[–] DoctorThirteen (15308) 2 years ago

Scream 5, by a mile.

[–] April-151-CT (10210) 2 years ago

Crap vs Crap? Tie.

[–] Tongue (496) 2 years ago

Damn that’s hard to say.. I thought Scream 4 was just ok when I first watched it.. scream 5 was better than I expected but still not anything that really impressed me .. I tried watching Scream 5 a second time and it fell very flat

I’d say they are too similar so call it a draw