Rob Zombie or David Gordon Green?

David Gordon Green. The characters in general are better. No hate towards Rob Zombie.

Zombie! Grittier, more fun, but not for everyone.

I think Zombie's first Halloween was better than any of greens Halloween films. I think they both have some somewhat unlikeable characters, but Zombie's were definitely more realistic. Green's films require nearly every victim to be beyond stupid or literally just stand/lay there waiting to die.

Nothing is worse than Zombie's films. From a technical standpoint, Green's movies are infinitely better made and Curtis really helps elevate the material when she's on screen. There is really nothing redeemable about Zombie's films, especially H2.

Rob did Hobo Myers first, and better.

I can't stand either of them. Both are abominations.

However DGG has truly took the shitcake for making the absolute worst film in the franchise by a country mile.

You can only look at Halloween (2007) and forgive it. What was to come after was truly shocking!

David Gordon Green. But this last one will go down as my new least favorite entry just above Zombies films.

Neither one.
They both ruined halloween.